Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14 by Thisisabadidea Thisisabadidea

Katie’s birthday?

No way

Brittany left the party planning up to you. She said she’d handle the present. You doubted her abilities and were worried this would backfire. Brittany would always just giggle when you asked about it and tell you to trust her. You three had settled into a nice but kind of weird throuple relationship. You and Kate lived together, went on dates and fucked like mad. You and Brittany worked together, went on dates and fucked like mad. Brittany and Katie went on dates and fucked like mad. You all three went on dates and fucked like mad. You’d all had many more weekend threesomes. You hadn’t done any more making Katie watch, you wonder if that’s part of Brittany’s plan. One late evening at work Brittany blew you to the edge and edged you four or five times, you’d taken the massive load she’d generated home to Katie and pounded your girlfriend deep into the bed, spraying her athletic body with the huge load and sending Brittany some pictures of it.

You’d planned a decent party, all your friends, all Katie’s friends, some of Brittany’s friends, everyone had crowded into your place. Everyone seemed to be having a good time. You met Brittany’s sister Casey. Casey was opposite Brittany physically. But very much the same personality wise. Casey was small and thin, almost tiny. She had shoulder length blonde hair, the same pale skin and light freckles Brittany has, but none of the other assets. Casey was wearing a flowy dress and flat sandals like Brittany was, but didn’t fill it out the same way. Casey has very small breasts and skinny legs and arms. She has a beaming wide smile though, she lit up the room. The fact that she reminds you of Piper Perri is a reminder to stop watching so much porn, even with two girlfriends you still watched videos. Katie’s older sister was also in attendance. You didn’t know her very well, she was out of the house when you met Katie. You’ve only seen her a handful of times. Andrea is essentially a taller, fuller figured version of Katie. The same long limbs and brown hair, but a much fuller bust, you expected Andrea was packing DDs inside her pink button down shirt. You could see her full round ass in the tight jeans she was wearing. The jeans were skin tight and hugged every ample curve of her ass and long proportional thighs down to her high heeled boots. She looks fashionable and rich and a bit like Gianna Michaels. You’ve gotta stop watching so much porn with two girlfriends. The top three buttons of Andrea’s stylish blouse are undone revealing a large amount of alluring cleavage and the edges of a red bra. You shamelessly check her out as people mingle and chat. Brittany looks fantastic in her loose flowy sundress, the front and back filled out very well, the straps straining to keep the flowered material up on her massive chest. The hemline is well above her knee, showing her massive smooth thighs. The dress doesn’t hide the trim of her black bra, the straps showing digging into her shoulders, and the lacy edges of the cups showing in the massive valley of cleavage. Katie also dressed cute for her own party. You’d given her a “birthday girl” sash as a joke but she’d put it on and laughed. She was wearing a purple tank top that hugged her very well. Modest cleavage showing, but with her bra not visible. Her athletic arms in full view. She was wearing a pair of fashionable high waisted shorts that went about halfway down her smooth thighs. Her long legs on full display, and enhanced by the wedge sandals she’d completed her outfit looks. You smile at her. She smiles back and comes to cuddle up on you.

“Having a good time baby?” you ask her, snaking your arm around her slender waist.

“It’s great! It’s good to see Andrea.” she replies, “I haven’t seen her in a long time. Did you raid my phone for invites? My gym friends are here and it’s weird to see them not in workout clothes.”

“Yeah, I did. Hope you don’t mind. Brittany though we needed more of your friends to come.”

“It’s okay. It’s nice to see them.” Katie nods her head to her gym friends, who are gathering around you in a small circle. You catch sight of Brittany, Casey and Andrea in a circle at the corner of the living room, Brittany is giggling and Casey and Andrea have awestruck looks on their faces. This is either good or bad news you think and smile back toward the gym friends.

“Great party. Very grown up but still fun.” Katie’s fried Lora says while beaming a smile at you.

Lora is medium height with a cute face, her dirty blond hair is shaved on the sides, creating an almost exotically alluring look. She’s absolutely ripped, every muscle in her tanned body is defined and popping as she gives you a side hug. She’s wearing a slinky black cocktail dress that shows her off in a way that makes men’s mouths water. The hem is at the middle of her muscular tanned thigh, the straps are thin over her defined shoulders, showing the much wider tan lines from her swimsuit. There is a slit in the dress that allows her left thigh out of the dress when she moves. The V shaped neckline shows small tanned cleavage, and lacy black trim of whatever she’s wearing under it. You take a moment to imagine it while returning the side hug.

“Well you look great Lor. New dress?” Katie asks her, squeezing against your other side.

“Yep. Needed an excuse to get one. And got a good one.” Lora answers.

Sure did. You think before turning your attention to the next of Katie’s gym friends. Karuna stands next to Lora. Karuna is Indian and has smooth dark brown skin. Her face is cute and dominated by her big expressive brown eyes. Her cute nose is adorned with a small diamond stud. Her hair is long, thick and dark. But it’s her body that’s really noteworthy. She’s wearing tan shorts that would have longer legs on anyone else, but Karuna’s thickly muscled thighs and ass have swallowed the shorts and made them into almost booty shorts. Her blue crop top shows off her brown washboard of abs, it’s tied just under her large C cup chest and showing plenty of brown cleavage and the trim of a lighter blue bra beneath it.

“I feel a bit underdressed. But it’s a fun vibe.” Karuna says, her brown eyes looking around the party.

“If I looked like you I’d be underdressed constantly.” Katie adds giggling. You take a moment to imagine both Karuna wearing less and Katie looking like Karuna and wearing less. You shift on your feet and curse the tight fashionable pants you wore tonight.

“It’s awesome to see everyone outside the gym. I also had to get a dress.” Katie’s impossibly tall friend Jillian says quietly, “I don’t have any clothes that aren’t yoga pants and sports bras.”

Everyone chuckles at this, and you take a look at Jillian. She is Katie’s tall friend from yoga class, she’s 6’3” and incredibly thin. Her legs and arms are very long and thin but lightly toned, everything is long and lean. Her hair blond hair is very long and sleek, it hangs most of the way down her back ending just barely above her modest bum. The dress she’s wearing has narrow straps on her thin shoulders, and is relatively tight on her upper body, her chest is very small and does nothing to fill out the dress, but you think you catch a glimpse of semi hard nipples through the fabric. The dress flows out from her narrow hips and shows off some of her thin thighs every time she moves. The dress would be long and tight on anyone else, but on Jillian it’s a bit shorter and loose and flowy, but somehow it works.

“Well something other than yoga pants certainly agrees with you Jill,” Katie tells the tall woman while smiling, “People are staring.”

Katie nudges you at that, she must be a little tipsy, you smile at her. You were staring a bit, but also imagining how bendy that long body is. You look around again trying to spot Brittany, you don’t see your busty second girlfriend but you do spot Casey and Andrea whispering over their wine glasses. You smile at Katie before turning back into the circle. You smile at Katie’s other CrossFit friend Lauren. Lauren would be a tall women if she wasn’t standing next to Jillian. She’s probably 5’10” or so, but she is completely stacked. Her hair is a natural fire red, every inch of her skin that isn’t covered in exquisite tattoo work is covered in freckles. There isn’t much not covered in tattoos though, at least that you can see. She’s ripped and stacked at the same time, curvy hips and ass, a bit of an hourglass figure but still muscular, large breasts and thick thighs and arms. Her green eyes keep looking down, her face is cute and rounded. Her black dress is tight over every bit of her. Her massive thighs are stuffed into the skirt, but it’s slit up both sides, allowing the thick tattooed thighs out for air. It hugs her ripped stomach and stretches over her large heavy chest. You shake your head, she’s got the definition of Lora but the mass of Karuna, and a chest halfway between Karuna and Andrea.

“It’s weird to be in a dress.” Lauren says quietly, “I don’t wear dresses.”

“Well you should.” Katie compliments the redhead, “You look amazing in it.”

You take a second to imagine what she’d look like out of it too. You smile again as Katie’s last gym friend speaks up.

“It’s great to see you Katie. You guys look so cute together.” Bianca says beaming up at you both, “But who is the big chick running around, bouncing all through here?”

Bianca laughs. She’s a tiny Asian woman, she’s not over 5’ probably way under it, you almost wish she was standing next to Jillian just to see the difference. Bianca is solidly built, looking like a miniature cross between Karuna and Lauren. Solidly built thighs sprouting from inside her shirt shorts, a proportional ass rounding the shorts out nicely. Her tight pink T-shirt hugs her flat stomach, faint lines of abs showing through the thin material. The shirt is stretched tight over what look like huge tits on her small body, but which are in reality large B or small C. Her black hair falls to her shoulders, her face is round and cute with delicate features. Her brown eyes are wide and slightly glassy, she’s clearly had a few drinks. In fact all the gym friends seem a bit tipsy. Bianca’s face breaks into a huge smile as Brittany comes bouncing back through the living room, helping to usher people out as the evening dies down. The only non proportional part of Bianca is her mouth, it’s wide and opens hugely to show perfect white teeth. Her mouth is so big it almost looks comical. But you do allow yourself a quick dirty thought about what she can fit into that monster.

“That’s Brittany.” Katie says, “she’s our... special friend. Who helped with the party.”

“I wish I had friends who looked like that.” Bianca slurs suggestively, “Better watch your man around that.”

“Oh I like watching them.” Katie blurts before blushing, realizing what she’s said. All the gym friends jaws drop open in surprise. “I mean, nothing.” Katie tries to recant.

“It’s your birthday Katie. No judgements.” Jillian says reassuringly. The gym girls all nod and giggle. “I bet there’s a good present planned then.”

“Actually Brittany is in charge of the present.” you admit, “I have no idea what she has planned.”

“Scandal!” Karuna teases.

“I hope so.” Katie murmurs before grabbing another drink from the table behind you, “You’ve all gotten my imagination running wild. I’m sure his too.”

Katie has probably had a bit too much to drink.

“Imagine all you want big boy.” Lora says, giving you another side hug, you think you feel the shredded woman’s fingers play across your bulge as she pulls away, “I’d better get going. Early workout on Saturday mornings.”

Lora excuses herself and heads for the door, flagging an Uber from her phone as she steps outside. You feel your phone vibrate just after Lora steps outside. Karuna was hugging you goodbye when it went off.

“Happy to see me?” she chuckles, “Maybe to see me leave?”

Karuna winks as grabs her stuff and heads outside to catch and Uber as well. Your phone buzzes again while you’re hugging super tall Jillian.

“That’s exciting.” the blond chuckles while bending down to hug Katie, “Have fun you two. Or three.”

Jillian grabs her stuff and flags her own Uber. Lauren is very obvious about copping a feel when you buzz a third time. You groan at both the grope and buzzing in your pocket.

“He’s a popular guy.” Lauren laughs, turning to hug Katie. “I can see why.”

“He sure is.” Katie giggles, “but he’s mine you bitches, stop texting him!”

Lauren turns away and heads outside. Bianca’s low hug catches you off guard, her proportionally large tits brushing against your bulge as you buzz a 4th time. You really wish hat would stop.

“I’d stay, but I think big tits there has something else planned.” Bianca giggles and turns to hug Katie. The tiny Asian squeezes your girlfriend hard before grabbing her stuff and heading toward the door. Your pocket vibrates again when she’s outside. You sigh and steer Katie toward the sliding door to the patio. It seems like the place is empty except for you two at this point. You and Katie step out into the cool night air and relax for the first time.

“They’re we’re hitting on you so hard baby.” Katie giggles as she passes you the pack of smokes, “You should check your messages.”

“Maybe later.” you say while lighting up, “I’m with you right now.”

You and Katie smoke in silence on the balcony, you can hear giggling and catcalls from around front as the last of your friends Uber away. The door slides open again, Brittany joins you on the balcony, wordlessly taking the pack and lighting up too.

“Good party.” She tells you, “everyone had a good time. Those gym girls were wound up about something.”

“Probably finding out I’ve watched you two, and his big dick.” Katie says, her drunken honesty on full display.

“You told them?” Brittany asks, shocked.

“Sure did.” Katie giggles again.

“There’s a couple of them I wouldn’t mind watching.” Brittany admits.

“Same.” You and Katie day at the same time. You all three share a good laugh.

“It was nice to see everyone. Even Andrea. We didn’t get along for a long time.” Katie says wistfully, “but enough about that! Present! What is it?!”

Brittany smiles and takes a big drag from her smoke, “Speaking of watching.” she says with a grin, “I’ve got a special surprise for you.”

Brittany reaches into her bra and pulls out a long thin strip of cloth she had tucked in it.

“I thought you said watching?” Katie giggles.

“It’s for the surprise reveal.” Brittany counters, throwing the cloth over Katie’s eyes and tying it tightly. Katie draws a sharp breath.

“This is hot.” Katie admits, “my mind is in overdrive.”

“Leave it going.” Brittany chuckles, and turns to you, “wait about 10 minutes while I get everything ready.”

“Check your messages baby. Have a bit of fun with them if you want.” Katie calls as Brittany leads her back in, “I can’t wait to see you again!”

“Have fun stud. Gonna show them your dick?” Brittany says before leading blindfolded Katie back into the house.

“And ruin their surprise?” You shoot back. Brittany laughs as the door slides closed and you’re left on the balcony in silence. You light another smoke before fishing your phone out of your tight pants pocket. You smile and wonder what Brittany has planned, you had joked about sisters but didn’t think she’d go through with it, but both Casey and Andrea seemed on edge about something throughout the night. You shake your head, it can’t be you think. You check your phone messages, sure enough there is an thread from each of Katie’s gym friends. You start with Lora’s message.

Lora: I wish I could have stayed. I’d have let you tear me out of my new dress and do anything you wanted to me. ;)

You: Sounds like I’m missing out. Maybe next time. :p

Lora: Don’t tease me. I mean anything. If you don’t get it good from Big Tits call me.

You: Don’t tempt me.

Lora: Night stud. ;)

You take a drag from your smoke and open Karuna’s message.

Karuna: If I’d stayed I’d have let you undress me with your teeth. But you’ve probably got a lot of fun lined up. ;)

You: I’m sure there will be other chances for you to be underdressed here.

Karuna: I’ll wear nothing but a trench coat next time.

You: What about just nothing?

Karuna: Is that an order? :p

You: If it was?

Karuna: Yes sir. ;) Have fun with Katie and those tits tonight!

You grin and settle down into the chair on the balcony. A message from Brittany pops up.

Brittany: Taking a little longer, be patient. Maybe take your pants off. ;)

You sigh and shift in the chair, these pants are pretty tight and uncomfortable, but maybe not yet. You open Jillian’s message, thinking about the tall woman’s thin legs.

Jillian: Two or three, I’d love to be four. I wasn’t wearing anything under my dress you know? ;)

You: I noticed your little nips. I will admit I was staring.

Jillian: I noticed that. I noticed what you’re packing too, I could see it from above.

You: Wanna see it from below? ;)

Jillian: I'd have to be on my knees. ;)

You: Long way down. ;)

Jillian: ;) I can manage. Katie told us how big you are.

You: Did she?

Jillian: Yep. I’m going to imagine it’s you when I get home to my toy. Have fun tonight stud, text me if you’re unsatisfied. ;)

You draw hard on your smoke. You wanted to show Jillian what you’re working with, but aren’t sure how Katie would feel about this. She did tell you to have fun, but that may be across the line. You’re still very excited about what Brittany has planned. You open Lauren’s messages.

Lauren: I felt it. It’s fucking huge.

You: So many beautiful women around. I purposely didn’t invite many guys.

Lauren: I wish you did. Or let me stay. My new dress is begging to get ruined. ;)

You: There’s always next time.

Lauren: I can’t stop thinking about it. I wish Katie let me see it.

You: I might.

Lauren: I’ll do anything.

You: Just keep dreaming. ;)

Lauren: No fair! I’m home now. I’m gonna do it myself. Call me later. ;)

Katie’s gym friends are trouble, you think to yourself. You’re not certain but you might be able to work something out here, Katie has been way more open to new things since your birthday. It’s dangerous, but exhilarating. And you’re still not sure what Brittany has planned. You finish your smoke and open Bianca’s message.

Bianca: I know what I’d do if I was in Big Tits’ place tonight.

You: What’s that? ;)

Bianca: I’d suck your soul out through your dick. ;)

You: Big talk from someone so small.

Bianca: I’ve got a huge mouth, and a deep throat. I can do it.

You: Next time?

Bianca: Anytime. ;) Katie told us all how impressive it is. We’re Interested.

You: I know. ;)

Bianca: Fuck the shit out of them stud. ;) Then text me when you’re ready for the next round. I’m the best.

You close your phone and sigh, this day has been long, strange, and arousing. You’ve been at least half hard since circling up with the gym girls. And checking out tiny Casey and stacked Andrea before that didn’t help. To top of off there are your beautiful girlfriends, Brittany and Katie. You grab the smokes and another drink from just inside the door and try to relax. Your phone vibrates again on the outside table next to the chair. You drag the smoke and pick up your phone.

Brittany: Gym girls get you all riled up? ;)

You: I was before that. Between you, Katie, Casey, Andrea, and all those gym girls, I’m in danger.

Brittany: lol. Like you didn’t plan it. You love being surrounded by sexy women.

You: Duh.

Brittany: ;) We’re ready for you in here. If you haven’t already strip down to your uncomfortably tight shorts. Before you come inside. ;)

You finish your drink and smoke and stand up from the chair. Your pants are an uncomfortable tent in front of you. You strip out of your button down, the cool night breeze feels good on your bare chest. You look around to make sure no nosy neighbors are around and kick off your shoes and socks and drop your slacks. You take a second in the cool night air, before opening the sliding door and heading inside. You drop your phone in the charging cradle on your way through the living room. Your heart is pounding in your ears as you head up the stairs toward the bedroom. Your mouth is dry in anticipation. Your cock is swinging inside your tented boxer briefs as your hand hits the doorknob. You take a deep breath to steady yourself before turning the knob and opening the door. There are only candles lighting the room. Your eyes go wide as you take in the scene in your own bedroom.

What do you see?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)