No Turning Back Now

Sarah's eyes were wide in fear and awe of the big, black cock that was poised to conquer her virginity. This was going to happen. John had left no uncertainty. He was going to fuck her. And she had neither the will nor the desire to stop him.

"I'm going to fuck you," John repeated. "I'm going to take your virginity. I'm going to fuck you deep and hard until I cum inside you. And when you go home, my cum will serve as a reminder of that hole belonging to me."

'Why is that the hottest thing I've ever heard?!'

"I'm going to fuck you, but you do have a choice to make." She looked up at him in confusion. "You get to decide which virginity I'm taking tonight. Your pussy or your ass?"

She had assumed he was going to fuck her pussy. She hadn't considered he'd want her ass, though he had said virginities earlier. On the one hand, her pussy was so wet at the thought of him fucking her. She knew vaginal sex would feel good, though would hurt at first. However, she wasn't on the pill and he had just said he would cum inside her. Was letting him have her cunt worth the risk of him fucking a baby into her?

Then...there was anal sex. She wouldn't have to worry about pregnancy, But she had never really thought about anal sex before. She knew some people liked it, but she had no idea if she would. And she heard it hurt.