Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by 11kestrels 11kestrels

Do you stop Nicole?

No, you can't

Nicole's hungry lips are all over yours as she rips open your robe, exposing the fact that you're naked underneath. "See, darling? You're ready and willing. The only thing you need to call is the fire department to put out the fire I started in you. But I can stop that myself" she coos. You give up trying to resist her as you watch James come up behind her, and lift up the back of her dress. "Looks like James is interested in taking me from behind" she purrs in your ear as she nibbles on it. Sure enough, he pulls her panties down, and undoes his own robe. You hear Nicole grunt as he drives his cock into her. You can't believe this is actually going on, but you're powerless to stop it. Nicole knows all of your weak spots, and she's using them to her advantage. She kisses and nibbles at your neck, causing the heat inside you to rise even more. Her skillful fingers knead and pinch your nipples in just the right way.

"Guess what, Katherine?" Nicole whispers in your ear. "James is about to make me pregnant with his baby. I took a few fertility **** before I came over to make sure I was nice and ready." She smiles wickedly in your face as she licks the tip of your nose. "I'm sure Arthur won't mind making you pregnant. Wouldn't you like that?" Her hand slides down your midsection, onto your neatly trimmed mound, and you find yourself parting your thighs for her as you sit there powerlessly watching your husband impregnate another woman. A woman you once loathed and thought of as a frenemy at best.

You moan out loud as Nicole's fingers dive into your wet, swollen slit. "You evil bitch!" you gasp.

Nicole smiles at you again. "Aren't I though? But you love me for it." Her thrusting fingers make you arch your back with pleasure as she finds your G spot. "Tell me you love me" she coos.

"Yes! I love you!" and you know you mean it, ironically enough.

"I've always dreamed of having you in college, Katherine." She nibbles your ear again as her fingers continue to thrust in and out of you. "I love you, too."

James continues rutting away in Nicole from the back, oblivious to the fact that he's about to make her pregnant with his baby. You could try to tell him, but you decide not to, and let Nicole have her way with both of you. You can tell once James opened the door and let her in, she became unstoppable.

Nicole smiles and whispers "I can feel him inside me. He's tensing up. He's about to make me pregnant."

"YES!" you cry out as the thought of Nicole becoming pregnant sets off a huge orgasm that you can no longer contain. Your hips thrust up into her still pumping fingers, and then she cries out "COMMIIINNNGGG!" You can tell by the way she's bracing herself on you that James is also coming inside her very fertile womb. You're all three still in the throes of orgasm, and slowly coming down from it. It looks like there's no way you can't be at least a threesome now. Not after Nicole got you to admit you love her. Maybe a foursome wouldn't be so bad after all? You start imagining sharing everything with her, and Arthur.

Nicole holds on to you for the longest time as she catches her breath, and comes back to her senses. James looks contentedly on at both of you like this was always meant to happen, and there's nothing wrong with it.

Nicole kisses you again, and smiles. "I've always loved you. James, too. But you most of all, and I never knew how to tell you."

James stoops down as if huddling with both of you. He kisses both of you very passionately. "Thank you both for a very interesting evening" he says. "But now I have to get some sleep. Sorry to be a party pooper. Work comes early!" He leaves you both alone, and heads off to bed.

Nicole sits on your lap. She hasn't pulled her panties up, and you can feel her bare, swollen pussy on your leg, still dripping cum. She puts her arms around you, and kisses you again. "Aren't you glad you didn't call the cops?" she giggles.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)