Nicole

"Nicole!" Sarah announces with a grin. "Well, I did say I would make it more interesting. Let's see... I know! I got the perfect dare, one that I think all the guys are going to love... I'll be riiiiight back, got to get something from my bag first!"

As Sarah leaves the room to get her prop, you wonder what she has in store for your childhood friend, especially if it's something that supposedly all the guys would enjoy. Nicole looks similarly concerned, fidgeting and glancing around the room. You quietly walk over to her, and give her shoulder a reassuring squeeze. She looks up at you and smiles in thanks.

Sarah saunters back into the room, and you see she's holding a blindfold and handcuffs. "Now then Nicole, I dare you, without looking or using your hands, to be able to correctly identify the dicks of John and Matt within 1 minute! If you get it right, your dare ends there. But if you get it wrong, you have to get them both off!"

Immediately conflicting voices and shouts are heard as everyone realizes what Sarah is suggesting.

"Hey! Why aren't I in this dare!" Tom demands angrily.

"How comes there's two parts to my dare!" Nicole asks.

"It's not really a fare challenge." Matt suggests

"Now now," Sarah replies, "Tom, no one said you can get out of the closet yet, so tough luck for you. Nicole. Miranda's last dare was also two part, and you didn't object then, so you can't object now! And Matt, are you really going to complain about having your dick examined by Nicole?"

Hearing no more objections, though both Nicole and Tom look less than pleased, Sarah walks over to Nicole, holding up the handcuffs and blindfold. She takes the blindfold first, and slips it over Nicole's eyes, making sure to check carefully that there's no gaps for her to see through. Then, she moves Nicole's hands and arms behind her back, and slaps on the cuffs, tight enough so Nicole can't free herself, but not so tight as to be uncomfortable.

"Now then, John, Matt, get over here and drop trousers! And neither of you say a word during this or use your hands, no cheating now." she commands the two of you playfully. It's obvious she's really enjoying this. You and Matt walk over, until your both standing in front of Nicole and Sarah. You share a look with Matt, and you see him shrug. With nothing else to do, you both strip, until your both standing in front of the girls naked. You glance over at Matt, and notice that size wise you two are pretty similar, at least while soft. You're both shaven too, so no help there. This isn't going to be easy for Nicole

Sarah frowns, and gestures for both of you to get closer to Nicole. You two oblige, until you two are both inches away from Nicole. You're now so close that you can feel the warmth of her skin, and hear her breath.

"Nicole, both of them are now directly in front of you. You have 60 seconds, starting.... NOW!" Sarah announces, and steps back to enjoy the show.

Nicole hesitates, trying to decide how to do this without looking or using her hands. You're sure everyone in the room is thinking the same thing: the only way would be to use her mouth. Nicole sees to have reached the same conclusion, and gets to her knees. She can't see though, and can't use her hands, so she has no clue where exactly the two of you are located. Having no other choice, she sticks out her tongue, and starts moving her head back and forth, trying to establish contact. The sight was almost comical, and you suppress an involuntary giggle.

"50 seconds left!" Sarah cheerfully announces. Nicole moves forward more, and gasps when her tongue comes into contact with Matt. Or more specifically, his balls. You can tell she wants to stop, to move back, but if she does she'll lose her direction. Reluctantly, you see her move her tongue up, until it's touching the tip of Matt's cock. She moves forward more, until her lips are around it. You notice Matt getting hard, and Nicole is **** to adjust as the dick in her mouth starts growing and lifting up. She tentatively runs her lips and tongue along the length of it and around the head, trying to judge it's length, girth, and "feel" with minimal contact. Matt meanwhile looked torn between pleasure and guilt, and kept on glancing over at you to see how you were reacting.

"30 seconds left Nicole! Are you sure you can do it? Maybe you should just admit defeat now!" Sarah taunted.

Nicole, realizing time was short, released Matt's dick, and moved her head around searching, until her nose bumped into your stomach. She once again stuck out her tongue, this time tracing your abs downwards towards your crotch. The feeling of her warm wet tongue on your bare skin had you hard before her mouth even reached down there, and soon you were poking her chin with your raging boner. She gives you the same treatment she did Matt, using her lips and tongue to lightly explore your member. The teasing touch is exquisite agony, and you find yourself almost wishing she would fail so you could fully enjoy her oral skills.

"Time!" Sarah announces all too quickly, and Nicole stops and stands back up, still blindfolded and handcuffed. "Now then, time for the moment of truth! Nicole, which do you think was Matt and which was John?"

Nicole paused, obviously uncertain. With no other choice, she decided to go for a wild guess. "Uh.... left is John and right is Matt"