Nicole

"Nicole!" he declares. Of course he pulls her name. Seems like the universe favours bastards like him. Again you want to protest but what is the point? You want the game to continue and you know short of him suggesting something horrible or illegal, Miranda and Sarah would likely defend his suggestions now. You stop yourself from sighing externally. And if you are completely honest with yourself, as your soft dick rehardens, you want to see what he will make Nicole do....

Nicole herself seems quite nervous, staring at him with wide eyes and you cannot help but notice, grinding thighs. "Nicole, we will start with something small" he pauses but continues with a smirk "Well actually no, it isn't small", point at his dick as he says so. Nicole eyes widen in shock and snaps her gaze swiftly to his dick before snapping it back up to his face.

"Suck on it"

"No! I can't!" Nicole pleads back

"Why not? Every girl here has sucked on it before. And every girl here has sucked on somebody's cock tonight." he reasons unreasonably with her

"But I can't" she replies with tears in her eyes. "I haven't even kissed a boy yet" she added, much more softly.

"You haven't?" you blurted out. "But what about..."

She cuts you off "Nothing ever happened with them, they asked but I always refused"

Well this is awkward. You exchange glances with Matt and you can see Miranda looks concerned.

But you can see Tom is unmoved and in fact just manages to suppress a smile. "We can stop here if you like" he offers almost kindly. Damn it, even you would be (slightly) thankful at him had you not seen him suppress that smile. Manipulative bastard. Unfortunately, you can see Miranda and Nicole believe his offer to be sincere. Nicole turns her head to face you and locks eyes with you. She seems to wait for you to say something but you offer nothing. Seeing that you aren't going to say anything, she turns her head back to Tom.

Damn you. Why didn't you say anything? You knew if you had asked, she would refuse, maybe get him to offer a different dare so stop playing altogether rather than put herself through more humiliation. You look at her, your best friend since kindergarten, a girl you have known for over 15 years. There is no one on Earth, short of maybe your mother, who knows you better than her. She has always been beautiful, were if not for your cowardliness, you would asked her out and something tells you she will say yes.

You grind your teeth together and stare at your knees. You are already regretting this. Why didn't you say anything? But you already know the truth. On one hand, your best friend since kindergarten, a girl you have known for over 15 years, a girl who knows you inside and out might soon be sucking on the huge dick of a guy you hate. The same dick that that has just recently used to dominate your crush, making her cum right in front of you. Your stomach drops at this thought. You being filled with dread.

On the other, you don't want this game to end. Who knows where this whole thing might lead up to? Miranda has already promised to talk about going out tomorrow, a prospect you haven't got the guts to do 24 hours ago were it not the this game and too much ****.

And on that same hand, you think shamefully, your dick hardening at the thought despite your disgust. Nicole, your best friend since kindergarten, a girl you have known for over 15 years, a girl who knows you inside and out might soon be sucking on the huge dick of a guy you hate. The same dick that that has just recently used to dominate your crush, making her cum right in front of you. And if the night keeps going his way, a distinct possibility, who knows where this whole thing might lead up to?

You look up, Nicole still looks conflicted. You notice her gaze occasionally flicking to his cock and back to his face. You can't help it when you look at them, your fantasies unwillingly coming to the fore of your mind. Her lips stretched, her cute cheeks full of cock. Her blonde bobcut-style hair and cute button nose covered in cum. Her bright blue eyes unfocused by the face fucking she has just received. And you know you didn't do that, in fact you could have prevented it. And Tom will brag long and loud about it, showing her off, telling you how much of a 'man' you are....

You are startled out of horrible thoughts by the sound of someone clearing her throat. Seems Nicole has come to a decision