Leave and find another girl.

You decide you have used Cyndi enough recently and, since she seems satisfied, you decide to move on. You grab a quick shower during which you realize there is one more change you think you should make to ensure Cyndi’s peace of mind. She is standing at the entrance to the bathroom when you get out, still naked, sweat-slicked, muss-haired and obviously comfortable in being so in front of you. She smiles as you look into her eyes and then her face goes blank.

“Cyndi” you say.

“Yes?” she answers.

“How do you feel about the idea of me having sex with other women?” you ask

“Good.” she says

“Really?!” you say, shocked.

“Yes.” she says “We agreed after our first date to a non-exclusive and purely sexual relationship.”

“That’s true,” you say, remembering the new memories you gave her.

“I’m also turned on by the idea of sharing you with other women. Ever since my first three-way, with my sister and her boyfriend, I’ve secretly wanted to try another one. I would prefer an actual threesome, but even just knowing I’m not the only girl you’re having sex with gives me a sexy, little thrill when I think about it.”
You are flabbergasted. You obviously don’t need to use your power to stop Cyndi from feeling jealous. You break eye-contact and walk past her to get your clothes. As you do she says “Before you go.”

“Yes” you say.

“I have this friend I’d like you to meet.”

“Is she hot?” you ask, only half-jokingly.

“Hotter than me, or at least I think so.”

“Sure thing,” you say, “Give me a call when she’s free and we’ll work out a time to get together”

“Cool” says Cyndi and walks into the shower.

You leave the apartment, locking the door behind you. You still feel unsatisfied and horny, especially after Cyndi’s little confession. Thankfully you’ve already decided who to see next.