Kayla goes with her first choice.

“Alright,” Kayla says. “Angelica Gutierrez, I dare you to do your very best orgasm impression. Moans, screams, the works. Make us really believe you’re cumming.”

“Ooh, naughty,” Angelica grins. “Alright, one orgasm coming up in three...two...one...”

At first it’s not really noticeable, but after a couple of moments her breathing starts to come faster and faster. Then she starts moaning in between the gasps, as she curls her toes and tenses her body up. The moans get louder and louder as Angelica gets deeper and deeper into her “arousal,” and she starts letting slip little interjections as she gets “closer”.

“Oh, fuck, yes,” she gasps. “Just like that, unh... oh, yes, aaaaAAAAH!”

She even adds some authentic-looking spasms as she “cums”, forcing you and Dinah to scoot over as she bumps around on the cushions.

She sighs in an imitation of post-orgasmic glow before sitting up. “Well, how was that?”

“It was... pretty hot,” admits Melody, whose blush is so fierce that it can be clearly seen even in the party’s half-light.

“Yeah,” you agree, almost as astonished as you are aroused. “That was...that was almost indistinguishable from your real ones. I’ve actually seen you cum in the ring and I’d still have trouble telling them apart if I couldn’t actually see you squirt.”

“Then how do you know this one was a fake?” Angelica asks you with a sly grin and wink.

You’re briefly left speechless as she picks the next player to have a turn.