Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5

But who?

Katie

You turn toward your girlfriend. Part of you can't believe you're turning your attention away from Nikki, but you know that it's Katie who deserves your first movie. Katie who seems to be as excited that this is happening as you are. You'd always thought she was the world's best girlfriend. You never knew she was quite this amazing.

And you wrap your soapy hands around her nice breasts. You can feel her hard nipples in the palms of your hands as you caress them, and lather them up. You give her a long look deep in her eyes. A look that says 'I can't believe this is happening.' The look she gives you back echoes those sentiments, until she closes her eyes and let's out a little moan. Her breasts have always been a particularly potent erogenous zone of hers. You hope she appreciates that you've literally turned your back on your cousin to give them some attention.

Of course, Nikki doesn't quite appreciate that. You feel her other hand wrap around your waist and take a hold of your manhood. Now she has both hands on it. You have both hands on Katie's great, excited, tits, and Nikki has both of her hands wrapped around your excited cock.

The moment is beyond surreal.

She clears her throat. "Ahem." Then playfully starts to tease you. "You don't think I plan on standing in my corner of the shower and just waiting until you two are read for me, do you? Not when this was my idea."

You feel her long soapy fingers pump your cock more and more. It's amazing.

"Besides." Nikki goes on. "What has she got that I haven't got? I mean, except for those really nice tits." She laughs. It honestly has never bothered you that your cousin's tits are a bit on the small side. You feel them press up against your back. You feel her teeth gently bite at your shoulder. Her voice gets quite. "But you know you want to fuck me. You know how bad you want to fuck me. And now I know it too. I just want to hear you say it. I want to hear the words. Please."

Katie opens her eyes and passionately glares at you, as if to tell you that she wants to hear the words too. Your girlfriend's lustful gaze is demanding you tell another woman how badly you want to fuck her.

You pivot and turn toward Nikki, who steps her body back from your body and smiles, looking up at you. "I want to fuck you so bad." You can't believe you just said that to your cousin. You can't believe any of it.

And you can't believe her response

What is her response?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)