Karen and Ashley are pregnant

Shortly after the Erica incident you and Karen get drunk and have bareback breakup/make up sex. The next morning Karen tells you that you two might have made a kid. Two days later Ashley tells you she is pregnant and its yours. Ashley wasn't on birth control when you were shooting her in porn. She figures it was the "super" weekend. She knew she would be close to her fertile time but with Erica eating her out and with the fun of being in front of the camera she took the chance.

She informs you that she is keeping the kid. She told her mom and her mom feels partly responsible as she wouldn't let her take birth control. You are the only other one she told and she didn't tell her mom about the porn or that your the only possible daddy. She wants to know what your role will be in the child's life. While you are thinking about this Karen tells you she took a pregnancy test and passed. She says she had a crush on you long before you started dating and now is in complete love with you.

(Author's note, Ashley graduated high school early and is actually three day's younger than you, several characters turned eighteen just before the big party)

Which girl do you chose?