John

“John!”, Miranda exclaimed with a smile while looking at him. She didn't feel particularly revengeful towards him and always considered him somewhat cute. “Mh, let's spice things up a bit to make Sarah happy.”. She looked around until she saw what she had in mind, grabbed the shirt Nicole had taken off earlier and threw it over to John before explaining: “I dare you to blindfold yourself with that and tell for all girls in front of you who they are just by touching! For every wrong guess you loose one item of our choice.”.

John was stunned. It was a dare he would have expected from Sarah or Tom, but he was surprised his crush was that bold. “She's basically asking me to feel her up”, he concluded in his mind. This was like a dream come true. “Sure, I...”, he started in a causal voice, trying to hide his excitement and play it cool but was interrupted by Nicole: “That doesn't even make sense, it's not fair. Like how could he ever get it wrong?”, she argued pointing at Sarah's chest. “True, no way he mistakes Sarah's big tits for Shortcake’s kid-sized ones”, Tom concurred in his typical asshole-manner earning him a deadly stare from Nicole. Of course her breasts weren't kid sized, she had a B-Cup which perfectly matched her fit body but the difference to Sarah was plain.

“How about he's only allowed to touch waist-down? That should make it harder”, Miranda suggested and John wasn't sure if there was an intentional play on words in her proposition, but he certainly agreed that it would make him harder. “I'm in!”, came from Sarah who liked the first variant more but certainly didn't mind the latter. “But what if he get's it right? Shouldn't there be a reward for that? How about each girl he get's right has to take something off instead.”. This time it was Matt who came up with an additional rule, obviously not entirely for altruistic reasons. Tom backed him up “Fair is fair” and it didn't take much convincing for Miranda to make that her final dare.

No one even asked Nicole if she was okay with it, which she wasn't really. The dare was harmless enough, she had to admit, more so considering her last dare and that all the girls had pants on. But it was John, the boy she basically grew up with. “Still better than that asshole Tom”, she reminded herself. And she didn't want to make a scene, in particular because she realized that with this coming from Miranda it was John's chance to get closer to her.

Sarah was already busy tying up the makeshift-blindfold around John's head, making extra sure he couldn't see anything and encouraging with a whisper “You go big boy, show her what you can do with your hands”. Not leaving him time to deny or reply, she shouted: “All right girls! Line up! And no cheating John, keep your hands below the waist!”

His vision was pure black when he felt the first body standing in front of him. He slowly extended his hands to the place were he suspected the waist and ended up placing them there on each side. Carefully he let his hands glide down a bit towards the thighs, feeling the rough fabric of the jeans. He had been so excited about the dare that he didn't even think about remembering any features of the girls clothing. “Idiot! How am I going to find out which one is Miranda”, he chided himself. Sarah had a more hourglass-shaped figure, he knew this and was pretty confident he could identify her. But he had never been looking at Nicole's ass, let alone groping it so he was a lot less sure if he could distinguish her from Miranda. And that was a problem, there was no way he'd feel up his best female friend. Particularly not in front of his crush.

Nicole was feeling more than bit uncomfortable when John's hand started to explore her waist. It's not as if he had never touched her, as kids they had there fair share of goodnatured tussles but they were kids then and it has never been in a situation like this. However he wasn't overly gropey, so she decided she could make it through. That was until his hands became more adventurous and slid towards her ass, giving it a soft squeeze. Her reaction was pure reflex: Jerking away a few inches and squealing “Hey!”.

John's hands froze in place. There was no mistaking, the voice had clearly been Nicole's and a wave of guilt flooded through him as he realized that he was just about to fondle his childhood friend. At least he found out in time and could now scratch her off the list. That left Miranda and Sarah. He let his arms drop away from the body in front of him and called: “Okay. I think I know. Next!”

Sarah gave her a reproachful look as she stepped away from John and even Miranda looked annoyed about her rule-breaking, making her feel like little kid spoiling a party and now being reprimanded by the adults. Whatever punishment there was in store for her though, Sarah apparently decided that it had to wait until after the dare as she stepped up for John's next guess.

“This one is easy”, John thought to himself as he explored the figure in front of him. Her hips were wide and her butt curvy which perfectly fit the statue of Sarah. Plus she was slightly wiggling her body, something entirely consistent with her slutty behavior. He really wanted to go on though, exploring her more, feeling those cheeks with his hands, but with a good portion of willpower he restrained himself, knowing that his crush was watching and not wanting to ruin his chances with her. And, he reminded herself, with Sarah and Nicole out of the game he knew Miranda would be the next. So did his rock hard erection. “Alright, got it. Next!”

Miranda was ready to take her spot in front of John, when Sarah grabbed her arm and stopped her. She gave Sarah a questioning look, but got only a sly smile as response. Rather than explaining with words, Sarah took Nicole by the shoulders and pushed her towards John again, warning her with a finger over her lips not to make any noise.

Nicole was alarmed by the turn of events. She kept quite, but vigorously shook her head and resisted the pushing. Sure, she had broken the rules accidentally, but this was breaking the rules too right? Miranda hadn't explicitly said it would be three different girls but of course that was implied… was it? Her own argument sounded weaker and weaker to herself, but she was stubborn enough to not just give up and held her position, staring into Sarah's eyes with determination. What she got back was a threatening glare which made her resolve crumble. She averted her eyes and looked pleadingly to Miranda instead. But the other girl was amused by the twist and saw it as just the kind of mischief to enjoy during party games like that. So all the help Nicole got was a shrug followed by a nod towards John.