John

Sarah laughs out loud as she announces her pick.

"I drew John," she blurts out, shaking her head.

You look deep into Miranda's eyes as she gives you your dare.

"I dare you to take me back into the closet," she whispers to you.

You waste no time, picking her up and carrying her back into the closet, she closes the door behind you.

"I have such a big crush on you," you tell her.

"I like you too," she replies, smiling, running her hand down your cheek.

"I was worried you wanted..." you pause, unable to complete the sentence.

"I was tempted... for a moment," she replies. She then runs her hand down your chest. "Fuck me!"

"I..." you start to respond, confused.

"Fuck me!" she repeats.

You quickly pull down her pants and underwear, and push your cock against her opening. She lets out a light moan. You look at her.

"Are you su..." you start to ask, but she grasps the back of your neck and hair and unable to resist any longer you thrust yourself inside her for the first time. It seems like a lifetime as you revel in the feeling of your cock inside your longtime crush.

"OH GOD!" she cries out as you continue thrusting into her as deep as you can. She pulls you in for a long passionate kiss, then pushes forward, pushing you against the closet door. She rides you hard banging against the door, harder and harder until you both cry out, your orgasm pumping your seed deep inside of her. As you try and catch your breath you hear a light knock and a voice.

"John, it's Nicole, would you like me to draw for you?"

"Yes," you manage to get out thrusting your softening cock one last time into Miranda, smiling at each other.