Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by zechs195 zechs195

What's next?

Jamie tries to help but might have made things worse

Jamie knew that time only mattered in the sense that that it would get dark soon and businesses would close soon thereafter. She was already fucked as far as her parents were concerned. She broke the window, they thought she got caught having sex, then her car would be found at a sex shop. She wasn’t going to be able to talk her way out of this. It wasn’t what it looked like but it would be impossible to explain otherwise. In the back of her mind she knew that no matter what she did to help Jennifer she deserved some retribution for cursing such an innocent person. So she just laid there stroking Jennifer’s head while she felt her Jennifer’s juices drip into her pants. She never imagined she’d have a naked girl laying on top of her in the middle of the woods but she was making peace with her demons. Tonight when she got home she’d have to make peace with some other demons if she wanted to free Jennifer of her curse but that was her problem not Jennifer’s and she didn’t want to burden her with the knowledge of what might happen.

After a while had gone by Jennifer turned her head and looked up at Jamie. She felt her juices soaking into Jamie’s jeans and also felt embarrassed for how she had behaved while masturbating. She just had gotten so into it and that wasn’t the kind of person she was or least it wasn’t the person she was when she woke up that morning.

“I’m sorry I...”

Jamie stroked her head again and shushed her sweetly but spoke firmly.

“I want you to take the words ‘I’m sorry’ out of your vocabulary. At least as far as it concerns me. You don’t need to apologize to me for anything that’s happened or will happen. It’s not about any debt I owe you even though I do. It's just you’re the sweetest person I ever met and I’m just happy to be along for the ride with you because I want to be there to provide you comfort and security.”

Jennifer tried to listen but she always felt the need to apologize for everything. She felt like an inconvenience and a burden especially in this situation. Still Jamie seemed sincere so she just smiled. They were the nicest words anyone had ever spoken to her.

“Are you ready to keep moving?” Asked Jamie.

For however long they had been laying there Jennifer had forgotten she was a naked cursed girl in the woods. She forgot she had a plug in her ass. She forgot she had miles to walk to just have the chance to get some clothes and she might lose them just as quickly as she puts them on. She forgot how she could be seen naked again by strangers at any moment. Life had seemed so good just laying on top of Jamie but now it seemed so hard.

“Yeah, let's go. I'm getting nervous about being seen.”

Her legs felt wobbly as she tried to stand and she felt ridiculous as she offered her hand to try to help Jamie up but that was the kind of friend she wanted to be. Jamie took it but used the strength of her own legs to get herself up. Jamie went to look at the stain on her pants from Jennifer’s juices but she didn’t want to make her feel bad so she just looked at Jennifer.

Jennifer tried to look like she didn’t feel like the world was getting really heavy around her but when Jamie looked at her she looked rough. She was of course naked, she had dirt on her feet and knees, her hair was a mess, she had a light sheen of sweat, and she was soaked between her legs and it was running down her thighs.

Jamie wanted to make her comfortable and feel safe but that was difficult with how far they needed to go and where they were. She walked closer and bent down and wiped away the dirt from her knees, given they were walking from through woods her feet were a lost cause. Jennifer whined a little feeling like she was being babied but didn’t say anything, she honestly did feel that Jamie was really good at putting her at ease but it wasn’t like she couldn’t fend for herself. Jamie put her hands through Jennifer’s hair trying to help make it seem less of a mess. She stood back and aside from the nudity the only things else that were amiss was her pussy and the sweat. She also reeked of pussy but Jamie wouldn't acknowledge that. Then she remembered she could only see Jennifer's front and something was in back that normally wasn't there.

“Do you want to take the plug out?”

Jennifer knew Jamie wanted her to feel comfortable and she knew that she probably thought taking the plug out would help her with that. The thing was Jennifer was starting to like it but she also felt embarrassed that she did like it. It hurt a little but as that particular hole didn’t naturally lubricate she probably needed a new application of lube. Still she didn’t want to admit that she was starting to enjoy it even though it was probably obvious given the show she just put on.

“Yeah, I'll take it out.”

Jennifer reached behind herself to try to tug on the plug gently but her hands were soaked in juices and also some sweat and she had a hard time getting a grip on it. She felt so awkward tugging on the toy in her ass in front of Jamie. When she couldn't pull it out she took her other hand and spread her left ass cheek out trying to get a better handle on it. Jamie was watching her the whole time and it made her feel rushed and she just couldn’t get it out. The tugging and slight movement from the plug was turning her back on too and since they were still waiting for whether the plug worked as an antidote to the curse it felt unnecessary and therefor frustrating. She groaned in frustration and embarrassment as her friend watched her play with her own ass standing in front of her. She dropped her hands to her side and pouted. On top of everything she was only trying take out the plug to hide that she liked it so it was all for nothing.

“I’ll get it.” Said Jamie.

She walked closer to Jennifer and Jennifer took a step back as she felt like letting Jamie take the plug out would be humiliating. She didn’t want her friend touching and pulling something out of her asshole, then when she got it out she’d see her asshole and it might not even look normal, and it would still be humiliating if it was normal but the plug might leave it partially gaped or swollen and that would be even more humiliating.

“Do you not trust me?” Asked Jamie as she watched her friend cower, naked and looking drained.

“I trust you more than anyone, Jamie. I’m just... ashamed to have to need your help with something like that.”

"Being ashamed sounds like being sorry. What did I say about being sorry?"

"You said I never had to be sorry..." Jennifer felt like she was being talked into this but at the same time she did trust Jamie to act in her best interest.

"Then let me help you. That's what I'm here for."

Jennifer felt it would be better to just get it over with.

“Um... okay, just be quick.”

Jamie went around behind Jennifer and Jennifer's whole body blushed as she got ready for her friend to take an object out of her asshole. This day seemed to get more and more **** and she wasn't even sure if the curse was broken so it might get worse.

Jamie looked down at Jennifer's full round ass and the plug sticking out in between her cheeks. She paused as she felt like she was acting on her own impulses and not Jennifer's needs so she decided to ask one more time just to be sure.

"If you don't want me to do this, just tell me. I only want to help."

Something about the way Jamie was asking for consent made Jennifer feel safer and more relaxed. She felt a partner instead of a pawn.

"If you don't mind, you can do it. Just be gentle, please."

Jamie got down on a knee so she her face was level with Jennifer's ass. Jennifer could feel Jamie's warm breath on her ass and she tensed up and felt her anus clench harder around the plug involuntarily. Jamie felt turned on by all of this and fighting her own sexual urges meant asking Jennifer if she was okay along each step.

"I'm going to touch your ass. Is that okay?"

That was obviously to be expected so Jennifer felt no unease in telling her "That's fine." despite feeling tense as she felt like Jamie was likely critiquing her ass since she was getting such a close look.

Jamie reached up and spread Jennifer's butt cheeks and Jennifer didn't expect that at all. She felt exposed and humiliated as the view of her ass and also the bottom of her pussy would be at its most lewd. She mewled as she tried to accept her bare ass being touched by someone else.

"I'm just trying to get the best look so I can make this as comfortable as possible. Do me a favor and hold them spread for me..." before quickly adding "...If that's okay."

Jennifer wanted to just admit she wanted the plug to stay in and avoid this embarrassing display but she instead reached behind herself and spread her cheeks while remaining fully standing.

“It might even be easier if you bent over... If you want.”

Jennifer groaned but bent at the waist until she was now fully bent over spreading her cheeks and now her wet pussy was much more prominently displayed to Jamie from this angle. She could also see her tuft of pubic hair on her mound but now upside down.

“Okay, I’m going to try to remove the plug. Do I have your permission?”

Jennifer was at her wits end. She felt the juices dripping further down her thighs and with all of this happening in the woods she imagined this would be the most embarrassing position to be caught in.

“Yes! Just get this over with.”

Jamie sighed wishing this was a moment of further bonding but it seemed like Jennifer was near the end of her emotional resilience. Jamie reached her hand in between Jennifer’s cheeks and with the tips of each finger grasped in between the plug and Jennifer’s anus. As her fingers touched the skin and she felt less lube than their should be and wondered if that was the cause of Jennifer’s discomfort on top of the plug itself. As she grasped it and grazed Jennifer’s anus and her perineum Jennifer let out a low moan and immediately let go of her cheeks to cover her mouth in embarrassment.

“Hun, it’s okay. You have nothing to be embarrassed about.”

In truth Jamie felt amazing that she could elicit such a response with just the lightest touch. She also didn’t want Jennifer to be ashamed of herself or her sexual turn-ons. As far as Jamie was concerned they were on this journey together. When Jennifer didn’t respond she just pulled gently on the plug. As Jennifer’s asshole stretched as the plug got wider she moaned again and tried not apologize again. At its widest point it was a mixture of pleasure and just a little bit of pain that was just perfect. Her eyes started to roll back as she let out another low moan before her anus started to contract again but by that time the plug was almost out. Then the tip slid out and she had the most bizarre feeling of air flowing into her anus. Knowing Jamie could see all of her back there made her feel completely exposed.

Jamie stood and tapped her on the butt and Jennifer stood back up. Jennifer turned to face her and she wrapped her arms around her stomach as she tried to feel less **** after what had just happened. She also felt the bizarre feeling of emptiness in her rectum even after her anus had closed shut that made her feel like she was missing something.

Jamie looked at her concerned if Jennifer was okay as she looked unhappy. Jamie wanted to help her get through this.

How does Jamie help?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)