James showed Emma nude photos he snuck of his sister

"One day when they are fucking James asks Emma if she wants to see a photo of Ashley naked. Ashley is pretty hot, of course, and Emma had thought a lot about her, so she agreed."

Sophia has gotten more comfortable with telling her story. She's calmed down now that she sees you're reacting well to the news about your girlfriends deviant sexual history. Sophia even has a hand on your half hard cock, gently stroking with you.

"So James pulled out his phone, opens up his google drive, and shows Emma the photos he's sneaked of his sister. It turns out that there were a lot of photos. This was not a new fantasy of James. He's been taking photos of her changing through keyholes while they were younger and apparently has continued this tradition whenever possible as they grew up. The clearest photos were all of Ashley sleeping though. When they were visiting each other or home for the holidays, she would sleep nude and he'd quietly enter the room and take photos and videos."

"After the photos it was videos of Ashley that James wanted to show Emma. He had gotten a treasure trove of homemade porn of his sister from his sister's ex. Money was paid, I believe. Emma still found it all to be exciting too - she admits to loving it all - the violation, the taboo. She found herself obsessing a bit over Ashley too. So she loved watching the videos of Ashley being fucked - and having James take her from behind as they watched. He'd call her Ashley when they'd do this - which they did all the time. Apparently the sex was great and frequent."