Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by reap3r reap3r

Where to now?

I stop by the house and receive two new pets. (Dominant path)

I open the front door and the first thing I see are Talia and Lizzie, on the floor in just their very damp thongs rubbing their pussys together whilst laying one on top of the other, my sisters look up at me wide eyed as if they were waiting for someone else. They look to each other and nod and speed up. I couldn’t help but feel aroused as they rubbed their lace covered pussys together, Lizzie was on top making Talia moan like a wanton slut.

“Girls stop this or I’ll have to fuck your both up your fat arses” I say and when I get no response I march over pull the string of Lizzie thong out the way and get my cock out. Lizzie seems to have taken no notice of me I catch Talias’ eye and see her close to orgasm.

“Oh yeah Tali, we’re both close to fucking breaking, the next to cum will be the Bottom bitch out of the two of us and will give our own arse up to Annie.” I hear Lizzie say before I grab her cheeks and spread them, I push my entire length up her arse. “Nooooo, fuck cummmmmmiiinnnggg” Lizzie cried out as she came and not even two seconds later Talia squealed as she squirted. “Oh Danny yes fuck my fat arse, you made me a Bottom bitch by fucking my own bottom. Oh fuck, Annie’s going to wreck my shitbox later. I knew Talia was your favourite sibling now I’m bellow her, fuck yes keep pounding my poopshoot big brother oh fuck I’m cumming agaiiinnnn.” I laugh as she squirms and her body shakes.

“You’re a natural Lizzie, if I keep doing this you’ll be an up the arse girl for sure” I say as I feel her rock her hips. I lift her up off of our sister and move backwards. I line her up so her face is directly above Talias’ paddy and have her lower the thong with her teeth. “If you are a buttslut just enjoy the meal Talia has for you” I say and I can see she’s close to another orgasm but is still **** to eat her twins cunt. I slow down and start removing my 10 inch dick making her eyes widen.

“No stop what are you doing keep pounding my fat slutty arse” she cried out whilst thrusting back to try and keep my dick up her arse. “Mmmmm please, I’m sorry sis, I didn’t mean it I’ll glad eat this meal to prove I’m a up the bum girl, a buttslut oh even the family analwhore.” She opened her mouth and licked her sisters slimy slit and moaned.

“Oh fuck she’s actually eating my pussy” Talia cried out and with a smirk I plunged my shaft back into Lizzies depths. “Oh yes sis you’re a true Bottom no doubt now make me cum with your tongue bitch” Talia moaned as she grabbed hold of her sisters’ head and pushed it into her juicy slit. After about 10 minuets our younger sister came hard squirting all over her older sisters face. I feel Lizzie cum from both my pounding her backdoor and Talia squirting on her face, it was obviously too much.

She raised her head from her sisters snatch and smiled “oh fuck Danny please cum in my butt, claim it as yours and oh fuck I want you to” she stops speaking her face flushed and she looks nervous.

“What Lizzie, what is it you want?” I asked gently she just shakes her head. Annoyed I try a different more sterner tone. “Tell me what it is you want me to do Elizabeth Victoria Johnson.” The use of her full name shocks both sisters “I’m already fucking your arsehole what else could you want?” I mockingly say as she cums again.

“Oh please bro make me your pet please I want to be one of your pet girls.” I’m slightly shocked but it pushes me over the edge just picturing her naked on all fours, collar wrapped snug around her neck with a leash or lead attached. I cum coat her insides with my jizz. “Oh Master thank yoooooouuuuuui.”

I look at Lizzie and then turn to Talia, she has a saddened expression on her face so I sit on the sofa and beckon her over to me. She crawls, yes crawls on all fours until she has her face level with my man meat. She grins before licking it and her eyes widen at the taste. She engulfs my cock and moans as she cleans it. I slap her arse and laugh at her, “you know Lizzie was right about one thing sis, you always were my favourite but that’s only because I knew she was a Bottom but was just too stubborn to accept it, but now I know the truth. You two are both Bottoms and either too stubborn or in denial to realise your true place.” I tell her this and she starts jilling herself to what I’m saying, I grin when she cums with my dick down her throat. “Look at you, you’re deepthroating my dick whilst rubbing your pathetic pussy to what I say. No I have a new favourite sister now and she’s going to enjoy her presents tonight as she gets both of the twins arses.” I watch as she once again orgasms from what I say. I remove my throbbing dick from her mouth look her dead in the eye and ask whether it’s her arse or pussy I’m filling up today. She turns around and lifts her hips up high and slams down making my dick enter her pussy, she ended up turning around so we were looking at each other.

“Oooooohhhhhh yeeeesssss Daaaaannnnyyyyy, just there I gave you my virginity, oooowwww, please be as rough as you can. I need to feel used and having my own brother fuck my unprotected pussy and fill my very fertile womb with his seed. Please bro breed me, put a baby in me oh please knock me up Mmm, Danny please fuck me.” She begged as she sat on my dick I grinned grabbed her tits and sucked on them, running my tongue over her nipples. “Ooooooooohhhh fffuuuuuucccckkkk Mmm aaaahhh” she cried out as she came hard on my dick.

“No” I say shocking her “if you want me to put a bun in your oven then you work for it” I tell her smacking her arse hard bringing tears to her eyes. “Bounce Talia, bounce like the little Bottom bitch you are” I watch as she rises and falls as she fucks herself on my shaft. “Play with your arse sis” I order her and she brings her hands to her glutes and starts rubbing them and spreading her own arsecheeks. I could tell it was turning her on and smirked at what I saw. “What do you think Lizzie would say or do if she saw her fellow Bottom of a twin spreading her slutty arsecheeks?” I ask causing my younger sister to moan.

“She’d probably line her fingers, which she’d sucked on for lube, up with my starfish and fingerbang my lusciously large lardarse and to treat me properly would say something like…” she stopped as she felt fingers push past her sphincter.

“So you’re a true Bottom bitch after all sis, tell me I was right” Lizzie said as she started thrusting her fingers in Talias’ arsehole.

“Oooohh fuck Lizzy you were right I’m was just in denial oh fuck Danny stop her she’s going to make me cuuuummmmmm” Tali came all over my dick and I grinned. I started thrusting my hips and watched as her face wore a blissed expression. “Oh Lizzie my arse it can no longer be yours we’re both Bottom bitches” she cried out macking me laugh.

“She’s not wrong pet” I say causing Lizzie to blush at the nickname. “You know the best part Talia is that I can knock you up and have no responsibility for the child as I get no consequences of fucking anyone.” I say before pounding her pussy, my cock, that had been kissing her cervix, pushed past it and entered her womb. She screamed in pure pleasure cumming her brains out and I filled her fertile womb with my virile seed.

“Oh thank you for breeding me Danny” she said as I was given her thong and I grinned and as I pulled my dick out her cunt I shoved them in it and flipped Talia around and entered her arsehole. It was too much and she was way too horny to care as she bounced back on my dick. “Oh Danny Mmmmaaahhh ssssooo good treat me like a buttslut.” I obliged and started ravaging her arse she came again and again, over and over she really was pathetic. I filled her arse with cum as she screamed out, “Oh Mmmaaasssttteerr pound your new bred pets’ arse hole claim it and me as yours.” Lizzie smiled as her sister joined her in being their brothers’ pet girls.

“Lizzie hop on your cunts getting bred now” I tell her and she’s shocked still. So I pull her over and make her taste Talias’ arse cream. After being cleaned my shaft had found its place in her slit. Oh she moans like a bitch in heat when I fucked her I also watched as she smiled as I filled her womb with cum.

I had moved my car to a hidden spot I knew about and came back and tied up both my slutty sisters with their arms down their backs and hands spreading their arsecheeks showing their gaped arseholes, they were both gagged and their pussys’ were wet and untouched since I’d fucked them. When I heard the front door open I hid and waited. Annie came running past and up the stairs and I silently followed. “Wait if your both tied up which one of you became the Bottom bitch? and how did you get tied up and gagged like that? is that cum? Who did you two fuck whilst I was away?” Annie demanded.

“In order they both are, I did it, yes it is and again it was me. Best of all you get both of their arses tonight, you’re my new favourite sister after all. You should have seen Talia when I told her about you being my new favourite sibling, she came so hard it was hilarious” I say as I slap Annies’ fat arse. She moaned turned around and kissed me. I feel myself being watched and see Jesse with new fake tits. “Wow Jesse looking good in the tits department. Come here” I say and the sissy sways over to me.

“These were meant for you, but seeing as I became the sissy I accepted to take the surgery instead of cancelling it.” She said as she raised her dress to show off her arse and clitty. I bent her over and removed the buttplug before using her arse to relieve my built up cum watching Annie start spanking Lizzies rear made me laugh. That night Jesse went home my pets lay curled up on the floor used and discarded by Annie, and as for Annie she is current servicing my cock like the slut she is. She had given me tickets to some event that was taking place, apparently there was going to be some celebrities there, a bunch of her hot friends were going as well so she invited me as well, with my credentials now letting me fuck whoever, wherever and whenever.

Suggestions in comments are welcome and encouraged.

Who should Danny have his way with next?

1) Any of his sisters’ colleagues.

2) New female/Feminine male clients.

3) Random stranger when he’s out looking for pictures to take.

X) your own suggestions

Also feel free to add a new path or continue a current one.

Who’s he get to fuck next.

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)