Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by fikka fikka

Did you underestimate Tom once more ?

He is only human after all

Tom had been enjoying himself too much grinding his cock between Miranda's ass-crack that he had completely forgotten his next plan of action. He was lost in lust, as he chucked at his villainous thought, I never thought I'd be enjoying toying with John's crush so much. Her pussy, her ass.,.. they're so divine. I'm gonna love fucking your girl John, I'm gonna love it!

"Miranda, you're so damn sexy ! I am sure that you have heard all the pick up lines in the book, so I just want to say that I think you are absolutely drop dead gorgeous and to be with you here, like this has been my greatest pleasure in life." Tom said as he roamed his hands over her gently heaving tits, cupping the outside and slowly rubbing in a circular motion and looking forward to a response from Miranda.

"You know you've wanted me for years. Let's make this a night to remember," Tom said in his best seductive voice losing patience.

Miranda simply giggled, glowing in the praises being showered on her, she heard it but chose not to respond as she swayed in her hypnotic trance. The ministrations caused by Nicole's frantic slurping of her pussy feeling amazing and unknowingly adding fuel to Tom's fire.

Miranda after all was not one of the regular run-of-the-mill chicks he would pick up with a corny line or enchant with the dimensions of his dick. Not that he had not tried those tricks on her before, only to be rejected again and again. While this made Miranda more and more immune to Tom's advances it only made Tom more resolute.

Miranda saw Tom as a crazy, persistent, lust driven admirer who she'd always keep at a distance but within sight. She didn't like him but neither did she hate him, because she craved for the attention too and from what she knew Tom had been her longest admirer. Since school she had seen boys fight among them for her attention and the trend has continued through her life. She wasn't spoiled or anything but this made her feel important, very important and she totally relished this feeling. It also had numbed her sensitivity to the feelings of people close to her, unless they were spoken out.

A living example was You - a person who had adored her for ages but she was totally oblivious to your feelings for her. On the other hand you had been witness to numerous dumb jocks trying to woo her, sometimes even your mind battling with your heart rooting for the guy to see how far he could get with the ice queen. Lucky for you most of them failed miserably but once in a while there would be one who would get to second or even third base with her but that's where she drew the line. Her logic was simple, she didn't want to be perceived as a prude but if anyone got wind that she was an easy lay, she would lose her most cherished possession. It wasn't just her virginity, it was something more sacrosanct to her, her importance. This was her essence... her ethos.

On the other hand there was Nicole, she disliked Tom a lot, rather downright loathed him. She had encountered a number of assholes but Tom was at a different pedestal. He could be charming one second and a masochist the next and she knew that, after all every single girl she knew, be it school, music class, other than Miranda had fallen for it. But the thing that irked her the most was not his constant attempt to screw Miranda, it was how he toyed with your feeling for Miranda. This to Nicole was just not acceptable. While you had two best friends, Nicole had just one and that was you. And for you, to see you happy, she would do anything... A-N-Y-T-H-I-N-G. This was her essence... her ethos.

Nicole was doing exactly that. She knew making Miranda feel pleasured would make you happy and that contributed to her sincere efforts, even though she was repulsed with Tom's dick in such close proximity to her face. Miranda was closing in on her orgasm fast and Nicole could sense it. She closed her eyes and doubled down her efforts to make sure its an orgasm she remembers. Grabbing onto Miranda's butt firmly to steady their movements she started to slide her tongue deeper into her vagina as she sucked on her swollen clit. Miranda was now merely seconds away from cumming, Nicole's tongue reaching places no other individual had managed to reach.

As Miranda's butt cheeks got pulled apart by Nicole's firm grasp, Tom lost the traction his dick was getting in its narrow passage which brought him back to reality from his lust driven drunken state. As his mind powered up from its groggy state he sensed Miranda's orgasm was almost inevitable now. When he was fully aware he cursed himself remembering something, Oh crap, I had made plans to ambush the unsuspecting girl,... I have to ambush Nicole.

Yes, Tom had crazy lust for Miranda but if he wanted to fuck Miranda tonight, he had to first take care of Nicole. Having fucked all the girl's Nicole knew, either by hook or crook, leaving them the next day ruined, she had an insight to all of Tom's devious thoughts and plans. She was smart, she could be smarter than me, he had thought but rejected that idea within a second. She had to be wrangled under control one way or the other, otherwise she could throw a wrench in all his schemes for tonight. But he had faulted, becoming too excited and lost in lust, his dick oozing pre-cum as he revered in the brilliance of his plan and in turn messing up his timing. A victim of his own carnal desires. He is only human after all.

Ill-prepared and in a hurry, Tom grabs the base of his shaft and points it downwards in order to slide it between Miranda's thighs and into the unsuspecting mouth of Nicole. As he does that his dick-head bumps into Miranda's asshole depositing a glob of pre-cum at it's entrance. Miranda's butt responds involuntarily and clenches as Tom begins to ready himself to strike. Nicole had felt the commotion behind Miranda and as her butt clenched she realized Tom was about to make a move but she still couldn't figure out what.

Gently she moved her hands from Miranda's butt and gripped her behind the knees to still keep her balance. Continuing to suck on Miranda's pussy, but moving upwards towards her clit, she tips her head a little to see behind Miranda, between her legs what all the ruckus was about. And that's when she sees Tom's one-eyed monster staring right at her eye, cocked and loaded, ready to pounce.

As Tom released his sidewinder missile in search of it's target, hoping to lodge himself deep into Nicole's throat, sirens screamed in her head, Incoming,... Evasive maneuvers ! Evasive maneuvers ! and she slid her mouth upwards to Miranda's pubic regions while still pleasuring her clit with her tongue. Tom did his best as he bucked, his pre-cum oozing dick in search of a narrow passage thrashing wildly along Miranda's slit. However, while Nicole was busy taking counter measures she tugged on Miranda's legs, her hold behind the knees made them buckle for just a moment. But that slightest of movements was changing the terrain completely and constantly for Tom's flopping cum oozing dick which was still gliding back and forth under Miranda's pussy lips.

"Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeek," Miranda screamed at the top of her lungs, uttering the word with the longest stretch of vowels in her vocabulary, to match her state and her own tight sphincter getting stretched to accommodate the bulbous head of Tom's dick. She had hopped in an instance from her highest mountain of pleasure to her highest mountain of pain. Tom did not realize but his dick was in urgent need of a release, more than he knew, it was craving for a snugly fitting tight passage. The one-eyed monster's head went in search of an unsuspecting mouth, tried to negotiate an angle with a pretty slit but finally found a resting place in Miranda's pristine virgin rosebud, and It - Did - Not - Care. It was in a happy place.

Please log in to view the image

Nicole realized that this might not have been Tom's intended plan but this was still in line with his intentions - to disrupt Miranda's orgasm and cost Nicole her dare. But Nicole tightly held on to Miranda and her lips to her clit. Either it was that or the fact that this was Nicole's first pussy licking and she was not going to take anything less, other than getting a heavenly orgasm out of the girl - heck she was going to strangle it out of her if the need arose.

Nicole was still not clear if this action by Tom was on purpose or an accident at this moment and doubled down her efforts on Miranda's clit. This was a challenge now, to be able to do an excellent job to counter Miranda's pain with pleasure, to make the girl squirming in pain jump ship and writhe in pleasure. And Nicole was always up for a challenge.

To be honest no one could quite well understand what had just happened, while Tom's true intentions will never be known it seemed to come as much as a surprise to him as to the rest of you. While both you and your best friend Matt were startled and almost ready to dash in aid of Miranda, Sarah had reached her tipping point finally. Watching the grotesque display of Tom's huge throbbing dick trying to spear its way into Miranda's tight anus was too much for the queen of fetishes to handle, not to mention Nicole subduing the helpless Miranda with her own tricks and assaults of pleasure.

"Oh yes, eat that pussy, rail that ass," she screamed out in ecstasy. With two fingers digging deep in her pussy and one finger in her own asshole, Sarah bucked wildly as her orgasm brought her down to her knees.

Both you and Matt have been closely following Miranda's reaction still unsure what to do, she seemed to have let out a shriek initially but now looking at her face she seems to exhibit a mixture of both - pain and pleasure. It seemed she was back in her happy place, actually it seemed she was in a happier place now. You can't help but absorb the effects of the scene unfolding in front of you. Your already excited dick making its presence felt even more.

As you watch Tom, your arch nemesis grab around the waist of your crush suspending her a few inches above the ground, to keep her restrained and controlled while his obscenely long, cum oozing throbbing dick tries to split wide open her virgin butt-hole, you can't help feel jealous of the guy, of his current position. To add salt to your wounds it seems your childhood friend is Tom's partner in crime as she licks, bites and pulls Miranda's clit with her tongue. Feeling you have lost one friend who seems to have submitted to the lowest levels of sexual depravity you turn to the other for relief.

Matt has always been your rock of Gibraltar, a shinning ray of light in the dark, your tower of hope. All these years it had been Matt who had been nurturing your spark for Miranda into this raging flame it was today. While you were always short and sweet in your conversations, Matt was a conversation stud. Something you always appreciated because he would routinely drop praises for Miranda on your behalf in anonymous cryptic messages. He had on numerous occasions tried to prep you with enough courage to ask Miranda out on a date, but it was always you who bailed out of it at the last moment. But his greatest gift to you was his sacrificing nature. Just like Nicole who would do anything for you, Matt for you, would sacrifice anything... A-N-Y-O-N-E. This was his essence... his ethos.

Looking for hope and consolation you turn to Matt and are instantly horrified. Your best friend has his rock hard shinning tower out in the open, slick with his pre-cum jerking off with his eyes closed and you are absolutely mortified with rage. You want to shout at him, scream at him, heck punch him in the face to somehow release your emotions, your anger. Your pent up anger for Tom had now suddenly shifted towards your two closest friends adding to your rage. The pressure unbearable in your beating heart and your throbbing dick.

Totally blinded with rage of betrayal and the constant pestering of your raging hardon you walk up to Sarah as she kneels on the floor totally spent huffing and puffing as she glows in the aftermath of her orgasm. Dropping your trousers to the floor and unleashing your beast you grab hold of her red locks of hair, pulling her face as you jam your throbbing member down her throat. It doesn't even register if she made a protest as you frantically begin pumping yourself in and out of her mouth.

Extracting animalistic pleasure from Sarah's mouth you look over at Miranda. She was still perched up on Tom's long tapered dick as the pressure of her weight made it's girth look double at the base. The dick seemingly following the physics of an iceberg and sticking only roughly around 10% inside Miranda's anal cavity. Even though the sight looked brutal, Tom's actions seemed to be gentle as he wrapped his one arm around your crush gently embracing her chest while with the other he stroked her forehead. Nicole on the other hand was all in guns blazing. She was restricted from using her fingers by the dare so her tongue was relentlessly working overtime. And that's when you hear Miranda let out another scream "OH, GOD! I'm Cumming" as her orgasm rocked her body.

Your pent up emotions needed to be liberated and your dick needed a release - both of them desperately. But you were still on the verge of climaxing, this act of rage with Sarah not your cup of tea and you look desperately for something to tip you over. As Nicole sat back on the floor, that's when your eyes get the full picture of Tom's dick throbbing uncontrollably and spurting glob after glob of cum in Miranda's asshole as he grunts loud and clear "Oh fuck yeah, Miranda,... here I cum, I'm cumming in your beautiful ass".

Son of a bitch, the pompous ass cannot stop pandering her even now. You brood as you begin to deep-throat Sarah more roughly and deeper now. Your mind simply is so focused on Miranda to realize that none of the girls who ended up giving you a blow-job, be it only a few, have ever been able to accommodate even half of your huge fuck-stick in their mouth. In other circumstances you would have probably been amazed watching Sarah's deep-throat skills but not right now. Your mind had locked on to one of the most exciting things you saw, so far.

Oh God, Tom came in Miranda's ass so hard,... my Miranda's ass, was all you could think of as you furiously pumped your shaft in and out of Sarah's mouth without a care in the world. And finally, that thought did it as you started to unload copious amount of sperm down Sarah's throat which she swallowed like a pro. Totally spent you let go of Sarah's hair and watch your dick slide out with a gentle "plop" of a sound as she falls back to the floor. The joy of having been used so thoroughly reflecting on her face with a wide grin.

Suddenly you hear a voice call out to you, the pitch is all throaty so you have a slight difficulty identifying it "John,... Dude,.. What the fuck,... My Sarah, what did you do, why did you do... ?" It was your best friend Matt running over to Sarah and kneeling next to her, caressing her face gently. As you look up you see the others are staring right towards you with their jaws wide open having seen what you did to Sarah, even Tom.

Feeling the finger of blame being pointed towards your direction you begin to lash out at everyone. "What dude ?" you snap at your good friend Matt, "you're the one jerking off to Miranda !"

"Oh my God, is that what you think I was doing ?" Matt retorted in shock. "I was horny, watching Sarah climaxing but I was also worried for Miranda, so while I faced her I closed my eyes and pictured Sarah, you dumb ass!" Matt continued.

You're very skeptical at the reasoning thrown at you by Matt but don't counter it for now and turn towards your other best friend, "...and You ! How did it feel being an accomplice in an anal-**** of a helpless girl !" you retaliate but this time your anger channeled at Nicole.

"Excuse me ?" the threesome responded in unison. While the explanation by Tom just flew over your head, Nicole insisted that she was just following with the dare and as long as Miranda seemed fine she was ok with it too. Your eyes scan Miranda's, begging for a response to Nicole's statement.

"He is only human after all," Miranda finally announced feeling pressured by your criminal investigation. You cannot help avoid the wide grin Tom now wears. As you move towards him to let out the rest of your pent up anger, he quips "Painal for the win !" to taunt you further and earns a quick elbow from Miranda to his abdomen knocking his wind out and sending him crashing to the back of the closet and knocking a box out of place. "You're not allowed to speak!" Miranda snaps. You wonder if Tom got the jab because of the 'painal' comment or for just speaking up, but finally your anger seems to subside seeing some kind justice being served.

Nicole picks herself up from the floor grabbing something and walks over to the bowl. She draws a name and stands next to Matt. She has tears swelling in her eyes and you know its your doing. As she is about to read out the name of the person she drew you see a hand emerge from within the closet holding the notepad. "You're gonna need this !" you hear Tom whisper, he's barely audible, as he lumbers forward next to Miranda. Everyone is too exhausted to remind Tom he cannot speak and let it pass... he Is only human after all.

Who did Nicole draw and can mistakes be rectified ?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)