Go visit the witch

You turn around and begin walking towards your destination: The forest. You remember the cabin being east of that river you found Lola on... Or maybe she was the one who actually found you? ... In any case, you make your way there, keeping your eyes open for anything weird.

You reach the relaxing river, no succubus fingering herself on sight. A bit disappointing, actually. Admiring the landscape, you continue towards your right and quickly reach your destination... gods, it looks even spookier than you remembered.

You take courage and walk towards the house entrance door, taking a deep breath before softly knocking on it. You hear some hurried, light steps inside and in a few seconds, the door opens.

You were actually expecting an old creepy lady with a big nose and a wart on it... But the witch is actually a... small, adorable catgirl? ...You both just silently look at each other with confused expressions. Maggie is 4'7 tall, petite with blue, messy short hair and blue eyes. You can tell she is a catgirl thanks to the two cat-like ears peeking under her worn-out witch hat as well as that fluffy tail moving behind her. She is wearing a long, patched-up dark-brown leather robe that you wouldn't find particularly attractive on someone else but actually looks pretty cute on her.

Some seconds of awkward silence pass before, without changing her expression, Maggie opens her mouth to talk. "You... you aren't an hallucination, right? I haven't slept in a while..." She asks in her squeaky voice, tilting her head to the side, one of her ears twitching.

"I don't think so?" You answer, scratching the back of your neck "You are Maggie, right? The witch?"

The catgirl crosses her arms over her little chest, frowning slightly at you. "I prefer the term 'sorceress'... But yeah, I'm the 'witch'... Why do you want to know that?" She nervously asks, taking a few steps back. "I-if this is about that chicken that... uh... exploded, I have nothing to do with that, I just-" She looks like she is about to burst out running away at any second.

"I-i don't know anything about any chicken. My name is Theo, I'm with the Adventurer's Guild!" You say, raising your hands in front of you in an attempt to calm her.

"Adventurer's Guild...?" She seems to relax, dropping her fleeing posture "Oh! Those guys! What's up?" Maggie exclaims, fixing the old hat on top of her head.

"Well, we were supposed to get some stock from you, but we haven't received anything in a while. What happened?" You say, the sorceress looks at you with a strange expression.

"Stock..." She mutters under her breath, rubbing her chin and thinking about something; after a few moments she bounces up with a gasp and wide eyes. "Oh! I knew I was forgetting something! D-don't worry, tell your adventure guys that they will get their stuff... with a little extra."

...Well, that was easy... "Alright...? Thanks." You smile down at her from up your towering height, "Do you... need help with something?" You courteously ask.

The kitty spends almost a minute looking at you from head to toes, tapping one of her feet on the floor. "Sure. Come in." She says, moving to the side and gesturing you to enter her home. You carefully step inside and she gently closes the door behind you.

"Alright." Maggie begins to explain "I've been working on a new potion, needs a lot of ingredients; Most of them were pretty easy to spot around the forest, but there is one that I really couldn't find..." You sigh... typical... A boring gathering task. You will have to spend hours searching for a random little mushroom or flower around this huge forest...

"And what is that ingredient?" You disinterestedly ask, an annoyed expression on your face.

"Human semen."