Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by Donny P Donny P

How do you proceed?

Go for it, and take it out on Kimmy

I lunged forward, pushing Paula onto her back and lying on top of her. She grabbed my ass hard as I kissed her again. Her perfect breasts pressed up against me, and it felt like heaven.

We rolled around on the couch for a minute before her hand found my raging hard cock. It felt so good, but then I remembered that we were in kind of an uneven situation. I broke the kiss. "Hey, since I'm already naked, would you mind...?"

She laughed. "Yeah, no problem. Just hop off me for a moment."

We sat back up, and she pulled off her red top. There was a lacy red bra underneath, and it pushed up her breasts in an amazing way. Then she took it off, and I realized that the bra wasn't the amazing part. Despite her F-cup breasts being smaller than Kimmy's, their pertness and perfect shape was so much hotter.

Feeling like I was about to pop, I looked down at my dick and whispered, "Please last long enough to enjoy all of this." The feeling I got was weird, I wasn't any less horny, but I felt like I could hold out longer.

Paula stood up, and as she wiggled her terrific ass out of her incredibly tight cuttoff jeans, I said, "Hey, are you still mad at your ex?"

Her eyes went wide. "Oh yeah, big time!"

"Well, I'm also mad at mine." I nodded towards Kimmy, who was staring daggers at Paula from her kneeling position on the floor. "How about we take out some pent up aggression on her?"

"Um, I don't know." Paula bit her lip, looking very conflicted. "I mean, that's not really the nice thing to do."

"Hey, if you don't think you'd enjoy it, you don't have to. But please don't hold back because of the mistaken idea that Kimmy deserves to be treated like a human."

"You know what, that sounds like a great idea!" Now completely naked (Oh my fucking god, those breasts, that waist, those hips, that skin, those legs!), Paula walked in front of Kimmy, looked down at her, and said, "Hey, dumb bitch, did you think you were going to have more sex with Rick today?"

Kimmy had both hands in her dripping snatch, just going at it hard core. She looked at me with complete need, then looked back at Paula. The pink haired girl looked like she wanted to kill her new rival, but she respectfully said, "Yes, I thought we'd at least get to finish."

Paula laughed with a malevolence I didn't know she was capable of, then slapped Kimmy. "Tough shit, asshole!"

I stood up and ran my hands up and down Paula's perfect body. I looked at Kimmy and said, "Please answer the next questions with compete objective honesty. Please get an extra thrill from longer, more detailed answers."

Kimmy gulped, afraid of what was coming.

"Who is hotter, you or Paula?"

My cheating ex tried to hold back her answer, but she could only keep her mouth closed for two short seconds before the answer burst out of her. "Paula is hotter than me!" A little shiver went through her.

"If one of you is trash and the other is a queen, which is which?"

"I... I'm the trash. Paula is a gorgeous queen!" The shiver was bigger this time.

"So, objectively, from my point of view, which one of you should I have sex with?"

"Oh my fucking god, please fuck m- ennnhhh!" She tried hard to fight it. "Her! You should fuck her! She's so much hotter than me!"

Paula jumped in. "Who has the better body?"

"You do," said Kimmy as she fingered her pussy.

"Who has the better breasts?"

Kimmy looked between her massive breasts and Paula's big but more proportional pair. "You... you have better breasts. They're... nicer shaped." This answer made Kimmy shudder a little, sending a ripple through her big breasts.

Paula bent over Kimmy and grabbed the kneeling girl's pink hair. Paula jerked her hair back to make Kimmy look up at her. "Who's better, bitch!"

"You're better! You're so much hotter than me! Guys want to fuck a body like mine, but they want to worship a body like yours! I'm a cheating slut and you're a real woman! You're better than me, you're better than me, you're better than me!"

If Kimmy had been capable of cumming without my help, she would have. She fell backward on the rug and twitched as she worked her poor, overstimulated pussy.

Paula turned around and wrapped her arms around my neck. "Oh my god, that felt so good! Can we keep her?"

I picked her up and laid her on the couch. "Well, I don't know. This might get old after awhile."

Paula lightly stroked my cock with her pinky finger, swirling her fingertip around my head. "I know something that isn't going to get old any time soon!" Then she gently pulled my cock to her pussy and lined it up at her entrance.

I pushed my way in slowly. I didn't want to tease her like I had Kimmy, but I also didn't want to pound her. This relationship felt good, and doing it right felt amazing. I moved slowly, working up to speed over a couple of minutes.

Paula pulled up her legs with terrific flexibility. She raised them straight up, then pushed them to the sides in a perfect split. This moved her vaginal walls around on my cock in a really great way. After another minute she said, "Fuck me faster, please!"

I didn't have to obey her requests, but on the other hand, I had to obey that request! I looked down at the most gorgeous woman I'd ever seen and let loose. It felt amazing.

A moan from the side made both of us look. Kimmy was masturbating and watching us with a look of pure jealousy.

Paula laughed, then screamed. "I'm cumming! Fuck, I'm cumming!"

"Already?" I asked.

"I do multiples!" said Paula. "Keep going!"

I did. With everything I'd done for myself, I was able to push her through to three more orgasms. After the last one, I could see a look of tiredness on her, so I pulled out. I went over to where Kimmy was kneeling again and said, "Same question as before, do you want it on your big tits or your slutty face?"

"My tits!" she said. At this point, she was so worked up that she kept moving her hands from her tits to her pussy and back again. "I didn't even really hear you before. I really don't want it on my face, my makeup is already a mess, but that would be so humiliating!"

The shiver that went through her on saying this reminded me that long answers made her even hornier. I had to ask one more question. "Hey Kimmy, are you a cheating slut?"

"Yes! I'm a disgusting, cheating slut! I cheated on you before, I'm cheating on Stephen now, and if you ask me to, I'll cheat on him again any time you want! I'm a huge, cheating slut and I need you to cum on my big slut titties!"

I shot my load all over her face. It was huge, I'd never been that worked up or cum that hard. My vision went blurry, but I fought to keep Kimmy in focus as she was hit with an even bigger orgasm. She collapsed on the floor, and I knelt down to put my second load on her big, stripper tits, then put my last squirts on her face. It was glorious.

When I was done, I wiped my dick off on Kimmy's ass, then went back to the couch. I laid down with Paula and wrapped my arms around her perfect body. We both smiled in exhaustion and cuddled until we fell asleep.

What happened next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)