Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by TheSpectator TheSpectator

What would you like to do with her?

First-time anal.

To ensure Flora isn’t just focused on her less-than-used asshole being stretched, you also teach around and knead her pert chest. Through your fingertips, you can feel her heart beating steadily increasing as you carefully penetrate deeper into her black hole.

Despite her discomfort, her erect nipples show the affection she still has for you. Her tightness swallows your girth, nearly sucking you in as you plunge deeper. Your hands are momentarily busy, but after diving nearly 3 inches in, you change where your hands are and place them firmly at her sides, tugging her slightly back.

Flora understands the direction but hesitates. “Give me a moment,” she struggles. “Just work slowly into me.”

You reluctantly follow her instructions and pull gently out before pushing gently back in. The tight fit is nothing short of orgasmic, but you have no trouble teasing her asshole with your length. This is done by sheer will— and the sounds produced by Flora. They’re more profound than what you’re used to, but still incredibly hot!

After what feels like ages, Flora caves and lowers her torso to the sheets, pushing her ass closer to you, forcing you a full inch into her rarely explored depths. You exclaim, pleased by the sudden addition of help. Her walls clamp down, pleasuring your cock from every angle… at least the parts that have the luxury of being inside.

It takes a few more passes, but soon, your indecent thoughts are soon indulged. Flora has grown used to the sensation of being ass-fucked, so she is braver… “Deeper, Warren.”

This time, you’re happy to follow her instructions. You tentatively work your hips into her ass cheeks. You’re eager, almost gitty, to meet her cheeks with your thrusts. It’s a long but steady war that feels primarily uphill. Flora unintentionally(?) cheers you on by letting her voice out, broken and graceless. You can’t help but wonder what other noises she’ll make as soon as you get going…

One deep inhale later… “Deeper, Warren~.”

You do as you are asked. You go into her depths. An even tightness grips around your wiener. Flora’s hole doesn’t want to let go of you. But now you’re becoming impatient. You want more.

Flora grunted, carefully moving herself just enough to test how far her limitations were. She realizes she’s been dipping her toes enough in the water, though. She finally whimpers, signaling that she’s about to hand the reins over to you.

“Alright~!! Fuck me! Fuck me, Warren!!”

If words could have been eaten, you would have swallowed her words whole. You squeeze her sides and send her straight back into your hips. Flora opens her mouth in a silent scream. The pain she experiences is melded with the pleasure that coats over it. Her mind spins, and works around her goes blank. The gross ecstasy your cock brings her is all that can register in her brain. Everything is either numb or doesn’t matter.

And then, after a dozen or so passes, she finds her voice and begins letting out moans that bounce with the ripples of her body as she is pounded from behind. Raw-dogged. Anally fucked. Senseless and blank— Flora doesn’t realize it, but she briefly becomes one of your whores. She moans your name and digs her nails firmly into the sheets as she is stretched on your old bed.

Again and again, without any pause or hesitation, you screw into Flora, using her until you’re finished, or she becomes broken. You listen to the slamming of your body and her incoherent noises.

You almost consider sticking your cock in her mouth, but know better— you must be wise about treating a girl that isn’t used to such sexual behavior. Despite that, Flora lowers herself even more, taking her ass-pounding like a pro!

The new display of your girl being such a slut is a bit of an ego boost, which was much needed. It feels like it’s been forever since you’ve had such an experience. Still, you remember it was just last night that you and Flora were in a similar position.

“You—you wanna know— the best part of this—?” Flora looks back, and you grab the back of her head with a fist full of hair, tugging it back until she gags on the air. “You— can cum inside me—!!”

Her words make your cock tingle, and your eyes widen. Flora smirks, but her smile turns into a frown as she starts moaning again. You glance down to watch where all your pleasure is coming from. Her puckered hole swallows your rod, and it sucks it back in while you pull out. You hadn’t intended to release so early, but your resistance is fading…

Your core tightens, and your breath becomes trapped in your lungs— you can’t hold back any longer! Everything you’re doing with Flora is just edging you at this point! Finally, you hiss through your teeth and send yourself straight forward, plowing straight into her sloppy wet pussy and begin to unload deep inside her ass hole.

Flora releases a grunt of her own before letting it come out as a deep and passionate moan. You’re so that if you had any neighbors that, they would have heard her. Still, you don’t let such a pointless footnote distract you from the incredible satisfaction of her warm interior welcoming your sperm as it is milked into Flora.

For a brief moment, you go numb to the world, and all you do is hold her, subconsciously thrusting your hips into your butt cheeks, making sure that your balls are empty and there is nothing left for you to give her. Once sure you can, you pull out and watch the milky substance drain from her gaping bum. It’s lewd, in a word, but overwhelmingly sexy in vision. Flora is trembling but only falls over when she sees you admiring your work on her.

She covers her face with a crooked arm and remarks. “That was intense.”

You lay behind her and wrap yourself around her. She coils in your embrace and soaks in your warmth, brushing against your sweat. “Did you like it, though?”

She giggles slightly and cuddles closer. “Fuck yes. When we’re together and unbothered with the ARS, we ought to explore our curiosity more.”

You lean back and picture Flora in swings, corsets, and latex— things that don’t quite fit her in the natural but perfectly when alone. “I like that idea,” you say, now hoping everything goes as planned…everything comes back, and you sigh. “I like that idea…”

It’s quiet for a time, but Flora kicks off the bed and moves to the bathroom. “Care for a shower?”

END (continues with the shower option.)

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)