Eeny, meeny, miney, Yui.

I was a little worried that my best physical effort wouldn’t be enough for Zynthia or Mary, but the next time I looked the two of them still had their lips locked, totally enamored with each other. They even rolled off the bed, but barely seemed to notice. Guess that’s two satisfied customers, even if I’m not doing the satisfying... who’s next then?

As if to answer I felt a tug on my shirt, that I guess I was somehow still wearing, from behind me, accompanied by a quiet voice asking “Uh, I, um, w-w-wa, uh, y-you...” and when I turned to look, I saw an incredibly red-faced Yui. It looked almost like steam was rising from her head, she was blushing so hard.

“Are... you okay, Yui? You’re kinda looking... tomato-ey.” I said, scratching my head from not being sure what to do with my hands. Yui took a few deep breaths, at least enough to get down to a “somewhat flushed” level of blushing, and continued “I... I’m not sure w-what to say...? I didn’t really do much... ‘ph-ph-physical s-stuff’... before Goltheum sent me here... What... what is this... d-desire welling up inside of me...? C-Can... can you... put something i-in m-m-me...?” before promptly flaring up in a burst of redness again.

Jeez, this girl really doesn’t know what to do with herself. And it’s cause of my desires making her go a little crazy. Well, the least I could do is be gentle with her, right? “It’s fine, just... let me try something, okay?” I asked the salmon-haired magical girl. Once she gave a quick nod, I took off my shirt, and asked “Do you want to get undressed too?”

Yui stiffened up, but before long took another deep breath, pulling her dress up and off her body, leaving her in pretty plain underwear. I asked “What do you want to do next? Don’t think, just say it.”

Almost immediately Yui shouted “Hold me!” before covering her mouth with her hands. Still quiet enough that we wouldn’t get interrupted by my mom, mind you. I chuckled “Okay, will do.” and stepped close to her, wrapping my arms around her body as we both just stood there. Her head only came up to about where my chin would be, but that says more about how short she is than it does about how tall I am.

Her body was pretty warm, which didn’t surprise me all that much considering how much she still blushed, and how fast she was breathing. It’s like she’s worse with stuff like this than I am. Well, was. Losing your virginity to an otherworldly queen who drains you of almost all your cum kinda has an effect on you.

Once she calmed down again, she told me “T-That’s enough, let go.” and being the technically-still-being-**** guy I was, I complied immediately. “S-Sit back down. O-On the bed.” she commanded, pointing behind me. I gulped, remembering how cum-stained it had gotten, and hoping it wouldn’t feel gross to sit on. As my butt made contact, I found it was marginally better than expected. Still bad, but bearable.

Yui started to smile, her face getting flushed again as she removed her underwear. Guess she got used to arousal quick. She climbed up on my lap, facing me, but not yet making any insertions. She wrapped her legs around me, my dick pressed between our two bodies as she looked up at me with her hands interlocking behind my neck. Within seconds, I held her again, somehow knowing she wanted me to.

She shivered, staring deep into my eyes, as she asked “T-Tell me s-something n-n-nice.” I wasn’t really expecting that, so with a flushed face of my own I stuttered “Uh... I-I th-think you’re a real g-g-good S-Star Guardian.”

“Yeah?” she asked, as she started to grind her slit along my length. “Go on.” I gulped, and continued “A-And y-your f-f-friends’re real l-l-lucky to h-have you, and I’m s-sorry you g-gotta be my s-s-**** instead of b-being there f-for them.” as my dick got harder and harder.

“Oh, are you? That’s nice, thank you. Anything else?” Yui said, her smile getting more and more sickly sweet as her movements sped up. I started breathing heavily, trying to think of something I thought she’d like, before coming up with “Y-You’re real c-c-cute, too. I-I bet you everyone b-back at your home t-town had the b-b-biggest c-crushes on y-you.”

“You’re not too far off... I actually got a few love letters in my locker just last week.” she replied, her eyes reflecting a breathtaking vision of wonder and happiness. It was kinda hard not to get lost in them, but it was made easier as she lined up herself with my now rock-hard, throbbing member. “Tell me one more thing, okay?” she asked, slit pressing lightly at the head of my duck. “Of course!” I answered, **** for any kind of release from her.

“How do you feel about me? About all of us?”

I was floored. How did I feel about them? How did I feel about any of the people I got gifted to me by a tentacle monster? What a question to ask a guy after he barely woke up, right? I certainly don’t hate any of them. In fact I want them to be happy with me, if I can help it. And I don’t want any of them to leave me, or be a person they’d want to leave either. Then it hit me: I knew the answer I had to give, both for her and my sakes.

“I love you. All of you. I want you all to be thankful I’m in your lives, the same way I’m thankful you’re in mine. I want you all to end the day happier than you started it, and I want to make that happen for you. I swear, even if I end up hypnotizing you guys, I will make you all the happiest you’ve ever been, so much that you wouldn’t need any Mindslaving to enjoy your lives.”

The moment I finished, Yui pressed herself down, impaling herself on my dick, her face a picture of bliss. She closed her eyes, and as my lips fell down to meet hers, my eyes closed too. We barely moved or thrusted anything, but somehow it felt like one of the best experiences of my life. As I connected with Yui’s mind, her Fertility adjuster appearing right where I expected it, I paused.

I stopped kissing Yui, and pressed my forehead to hers, saying “Yui, I’ve been making everyone’s fertility get raised as I had sex with them, since I wanted them to get pregnant. Since I wanted to get them pregnant. Are you... are you okay with me doing the same to you?”

She seemed taken aback, at first, but as she stared into my eyes, she smiled. “If you really meant everything you said, then I wouldn’t stop you.” I was floored. Could anyone so generous and kind really exist in real life? Was it possible? Overcome with emotion, I embraced her tighter, until our heads were pressed into each other’s shoulders.

“Get pregnant, get pregnant, get pregnant...” I repeated, suddenly bursting with energy as I thrusted into her depths as fast as I could. As if trying to give the words power, I raised Yui’s fertility closer and closer to the max with every utterance. It was like I was possessed with some baby-making demon that could barely be satisfied.

But then, out of nowhere, Yui surprised me yet again.

“Please...! Knock me up...!”

Immediately, I burst like an overworked dam, spurting every ounce of cum that I had into Yui’s walls. And in the midst of it all, I couldn’t stop thrusting, trying to reach deeper and deeper somehow, trying to fulfill her last request as much as I could before she was satisfied.

Eventually, with a final moan, I was finished, realizing I probably dirtied my sheets even more, only to find that most of what I shot out stayed within Yui herself. I could tell, since there was a slight bulge now visible in her abdomen. Not because it got sucked up into her womb, mind you, that’s just plain hentai showmanship. If anything, it’d be just in her vaginal passage.

As I removed my cock, she quickly moved her hand to keep as much inside as she could. “Thank you,” she said, “for fulfilling my request.” before making her way to the bathroom. Maybe it was so she could get a band-aid to keep her slit closed? Or maybe so she could sit on the toilet where all my spunk could drain out without staining something...

Either way, I was feeling quite refreshed. Turns out semi-consensual sex is nice for the body and mind. But I wasn’t done yet. As standing before me, still, was the last person affected by this instance of Rapey Slaves: Victoria Valentine.