Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by kinkygeek kinkygeek

Whom do you call?

Diane--Suzy's sister

You decide to give your sister-in-law Diane a call. She is two years younger than Suzy, and a little shorter and more curvy. She has a spunky attitude too. You recall how she would interrupt you and Suzy in the middle of hot passionate sex whenever you two spent the night at her parents' house when you were dating, telling you two to either keep it down or let her watch. Although Suzy would have been mortified at the thought of it, you secretly always wanted to go for option B. You think Diane probably did too because after you and Suzy finished fucking you could often hear her pleasuring herself to two or three orgasms in the next room.

You had often wondered what it would be like to fuck Diane, but you never got the chance during those visits because Suzy was always close by. You always suspected she wanted it too, but you were never quite sure until the day of your wedding. Diane was Suzy's maid of honor, and part of her job was to keep you from seeing Suzy until the ceremony that evening. Even though you had thoroughly fucked three strippers at your bachelor party the night before, you were still craving more and wouldn't be able to wait until after the reception. You tried to sneak past Diane to see Suzy for a quickie, but she caught you and dragged you away. When you explained that you felt like you would explode if you couldn't fuck Suzy, she offered to let you fuck her instead.

Diane pulled you into a nearby broom closet, sat on a stack of containers in the corner, hiked up her dress, and leaned back. "No panties?" you asked, staring at her neatly trimmed pubic hair and luscious pink vulva.

"I... um... lost a bet. Sorry, I can't tell you more than that," she said. "Now hurry up and fuck me before Suzy starts looking for me."

You moved into position to give her some cunnilingus, but she stopped you with her legs. "No time for that," she told you sternly. "Besides, I'm already plenty wet and horny. Your best man told me all about your bachelor party. I just wish I could have been one of those strippers. I've wanted your cock so badly these past couple of years."

That was all the encouragement you needed to drop your pants and plunge right in. You will never forget looking into Diane's face that moment. It was so much like Suzy's face on the night of that Halloween party two years earlier, but the subtle differences made this moment that much more exciting. She wrapped her legs around your waist and pulled you eagerly into her. You pounded her hard and deep, and she answered each thrust with an enthusiastic, "Yes! Yes! Fuck! Harder! HARDER!"

You felt your balls tighten and told her you were about to cum. She pushed you off of her and slid off the containers to kneel down in front of you so she could swallow your cum. She wasn't quite fast enough to get your cock in her mouth before you started ejaculating, and the first shot plastered her across the cheek. The second shot ran up along the side of her nose and nearly into her hair. By the third shot, she managed to wrap her mouth around your cock and drank down the rest of your load.

"There. Satisfied now?" she said as she wiped your cum off of her face with a tissue. You nodded breathlessly as you pulled your pants back up and fastened your belt. "Good, now let's get out of here before someone walks in on us. If Suzy ever finds out about this, she'll kill us both."

Suzy never found out, fortunately, but you never had another opportunity to fuck Diane again after that. A few months after the wedding, she started seeing this rich entrepreneur and married him the following year. Their relationship was a turbulent one though. Whenever his company did well, their marriage was on the rocks. Whenever their stocks took a dive, they were able to patch things up and draw closer together. Last year though, his company had record-breaking earnings and the extra attention her husband gave to the business ended up tanking their marriage. They've been divorced for three months now, and Diane moved to a nearby neighborhood to be closer to her sister.

You've been itching to get another opportunity to fuck Diane for the past five years, and it looks like you may finally have your chance tonight.

You call Diane's phone. It rings twice before she answers.

"Hello?"

"Hey Diane, it's Dave."

"Oh, hey Dave, what's up?"

"Oh, not much. I just dropped Suzy off at the airport for her conference this week, so I have the house to myself for a few days."

"Yes, she was telling me about that conference. She seemed pretty excited to go."

"Uh huh, she's been looking forward to it all month. Listen, I was wondering if you would like to come over for dinner tonight. I have a couple of steaks in the freezer that I was going to grill before Suzy left, but never got the chance."

"Um..."

She seems hesitant. You're pretty sure she knows what you're hoping will happen this evening, but you have no idea if she wants it too. Nervously, you hold your breath while she takes what seems like an eternity to answer.

"Sure, I would love to come over. Is 8:00 ok?"

Relief washes over you as you slowly exhale. You can't help but grin when you answer.

"Yes, 8:00 is perfect. "

"Great! I'll bring a bottle of wine."

"Sounds good. I'll see you then."

"See you then. Bye"

"Bye."

'click'

That went well. You're already getting hard thinking about what you would like to do with Diane after dinner tonight. You get the steaks out of the freezer so they can defrost and start getting ready for Diane's visit tonight.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)