Cum inside of her

There's no going back now, or so you tell yourself. You pull your finger out of her ass and grab Anna by the hips as you make your final thrusts. There's the unmistakable tightening of your balls as you begin to cum deep and hard inside of your ex-girlfriend's pussy.

"I'm cumming!" you shout. Wave after wave of hot semen explodes out of your cock, coating the insides of Anna. She clenches her lips even tighter around you, drawing more and more cum out of your shaft.

As you orgasm, Anna releases one of your arms and reaches between her legs. She furiously fingers her pussy and clit, driven wild by the thought of you cumming inside her. A moment after your ecstasy peaks, she too begins to cum. Her back arches and she lurches back violently onto your cock. She repeats this motion, making your balls slap against her ass as a torrent of pleasure ripples through her body.

"Fuck!" is all she can say as you feel her juice flood onto the base of your shaft and down both of your legs.

In a moment it's over, and both of you return to reality.

"That was fucking amazing," she says, "I didn't know you could be so bossy."

"I didn't know you could be so submissive," you respond. You slowly begin to pull your dick out of her sopping wet pussy. With a pop you're free and you watch as a stream of cum begins to pour out of Anna's well-used pussy.

"It feels like I'm really going to need to clean up well," says Anna as she stands up and looks down at her dripping pussy.

"You're welcome to join me in the shower if you want, or you can use the tissues on the end table to clean up. I can promise you some more fun if you do join me, but either way I'm hoping this isn't just a one time thing. I really enjoyed fucking Penny's boyfriend." And with that, Anna begins to head toward the bathroom. She's clearly leaving it up to you to decide what to do next.

You definitely don't want to break up with Penny, but you can't deny that you enjoyed fucking Anna. Was that her plan all along? Does she want to keep you as a secret fuck buddy? If that's true, then this whole day was a setup, but do you even care? Time to decide what to do next.