Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by LiteraryLover LiteraryLover

Fucking with Ashley's head or see who's at the door?

Cousin Sarah

Opening the door, I see my cousin Sarah frozen while trying to ring the door bell. I can't help but smile

As creepy as it sounds, and that's coming from a guy who just fucked his time frozen sister, I had always had a crush on Sarah. We're the same age, so we always were around each other growing up, borrowing each others toys, all that. When we were going through puberty and we went swimming together I got my first boner seeing her in her new swimsuit. And a year or two ago I began to masturbate to pictures of her on her social media.

And now here she is, putty in my hands. As I brushed some of her curly brown shoulder-length hair away from her face, I got the devilish idea of bending her over Ashley and fucking her like that. I planted a kiss on her beautiful, full lips and stripped her nude. I marveled at her C cup tits and freshly shaven pussy. Seeing Sarah nude after all the years lusting over her made me feel like a kid at Christmas and only that much more excited to finally fuck her. I decided to keep her black silk bra and teal panties with little red hearts as sort of trophies, and figured I'd keep Ashley's too when I was done and hide Sarah's regular clothes in the backyard.

I brought Sarah, who was surprisingly light, to Ashley's room. 'Is she lighter because of time being stopped or is she just always really light?" I wondered to myself. I go and fetch Ashley from the kitchen, stripping her as well. I placed Ashley laying on her bed as she had been earlier. I bent Sarah over Ashley making her holes dick height to me. 'Perfect.' I thought to myself.

Fuck which one of Sarah's holes?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)