Carrie, Rachel, and You

That night, you walk up to Charlie’s house to find Rachel sitting on the front steps. She gives you a beautiful smile.

“Hey! I’m glad you could make it.” Rachel says, and you pull in Charlie's little sister for a tight hug, which she responds to welcomingly. Once she breaks the hug, she leads you inside the house. You see Carrie, wearing a tight violet dress, and her blond hair pulled back in an elegant bun. She smiles at you, and you turn to see Lee, who’s a weakling, and drunk in an armchair. He has no muscles, hippie brown hair, and a strange lei around his neck.

Carrie frowns as Lee adds a seventh beer to the cluster, and leads Rachel and you over to a small, secluded table.

“Hey, sorry. Jon, right? But when Lee gets drunk, he gets a little... temperamental.” Carrie acts wonderfully. You touch her hand.

“Does he ever hurt you?” you ask, mostly for Rachel’s benefit, and both Lewis women beam at you.

“Oh, no. Lee’s a kind soul.” Carrie smiles and walks away. She returns quickly with bowls of soup and grilled cheese.

“Aw! Grilled cheese! My favorite!” Rachel laughs, smiling at her mother.

“Oh, don’t look at me. It was Jon who asked me to make it for you.” Carrie says, and walks away, shooting you a flirty wink that Rachel doesn’t see.

“Jon! Really? That’s really sweet.” Rachel smiles, “But how’d you know?”

“Oh, I just asked Charlie.” you shrug, and Rachel laces hands with you.

“Well, thank you.” Rachel smiles sincerely. You know, it’s amazing how easy it is to seduce a girl with her mother on your side. You squeeze her hand.

“No problem.” you say. You eat your grilled cheese and soup, before Rachel leads you upstairs. You wink at Carrie, and she follows you upstairs, waiting outside Rachel’s door. Inside Rachel’s room, the pretty blond brushes her hair out of her face and smiles at you. You decide quickly that caring time is over and jump her, kissing her dominantly. Rachel struggles against it, but you just laugh and rip her tank top in half, exposing her heaving D cup tits, which were braless.

“Expecting something?” you toy, flicking her rock hard nipples. She arches her body underneath your hand as it slides down from her breasts and slips into her jean shorts and into her panties until you’re stroking her pussy, much to Rachel’s hatred and pleasure.

Much like Carrie, Rachel is overwhelmed with pleasure, but grapples with the morality of succumbing. You flip her over and grab a knife from your pocket, and slash her jeans open, pulling the article of clothing off her. Rachel screams as you grab her panties, but Carrie enters, and kisses you before going to Rachel.

“Mom! Holy shit! You’re with him?” Rachel exclaims. You nod at the door, and Carrie closes it.

“Why?” Rachel sobs as you cut off her panties. You kiss down her back and the girl shivers under your lips. Carrie grabs Rachel’s face and starts kissing her as you unbuckle your jeans and let your 9 1/2 inch cock pop out and it nudged Rachel's asscheek, and she shrieks, but Carrie cradles her against her tits, stroking her hair and kissing her as you line up your cock. Carrie nods at you, and you slam 9 1/2 inches of cock inside Rachel's virgin pussy. You feel her cherry pop, and Carrie soothes her, kissing her lips and neck and stuff to keep Rachel comfortable as you start plowing into her tight pussy. Rachel moans very loudly as you **** her previously innocent pussy.

“If you ever want sex again, you’re going to pretend to be my girlfriend. Or actually be my girlfriend.” you say as you hear the front door opens.

“And keep me a secret.” Carrie whispers before sliding under the bed as you grip Rachel’s hips and plow harder. Rachel arches and thrashes and moans wildly as you fuck her. Charlie opens the door, Amy under his arm, and you pull out of Rachel, pretending to be guilty and Amy’s eyes practically bug out at the size of your cock.

“Were you **** my sister?” Charlie yells.

“Oh, shut up. Charlie, I love him. We’re dating now, and I wanted to not be a virgin anymore.” Rachel steps in smoothly. Charlie gapes at that, his eyes noticeably locked on Rachel’s sweaty tits. He doesn’t notice Amy’s hungry look at your throbbing, thick, meaty cock. Charlie shakes off Rachel’s vision of beauty, and turns and walks out. Amy bites her lip at your cock, horny, but follows Charlie out of Rachel’s room. Rachel slams against you, kissing you fiercely.

“That made me so wet! Fucking my big brother’s bully! And did you see how Amy looked at your cock?” Rachel laughs giddily against your lips. Carrie slides out from under the bed and kisses Rachel and you lovingly.

“Okay. Carrie, I need your help with Amy. Rachel, who’s Amy’s best friend?” you ask. The pretty blond thinks.

“A girl named Ella. She’s gorgeous.” Rachel smiles. You pull her in for a deep kiss while Carrie kisses and sucks on her neck.

“Good. Get her to fuck me. How best to convince Amy then to say her BFF loved it?” you smile.