Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by Zingiber Zingiber

Where do you begin?

Best Friend's ass first

Jennifer crawls up on the old towels next to Chris. Now there are two bare butts mooning you from your bed, Jennifer's round and smooth, Chris's squarer with a little blond hair in the cleft, each ass lubed up and ready for cock. You smile as you consider your options, stroking more lube on yourself from Jennifer's pump bottle. It's got a fruity scent that you'll remember.

You lean forward and kiss Jennifer on the butt cheek. "You were so hot and open. I want to try your ass. But not now. Later." Your fingertips are a little sticky. You've still got a little bit of Jennifer there.

Jennifer giggles. "Deal," she says. "Later." She sits up to see how things proceed.

You squeeze Chris's butt. "Ready up, pal," you say. "Got a rocket mission to your anus."

"Oh, yeah," Jennifer breathes.

"Passing drill, Chris," you tell your teammate. "Get ready to receive."

Chris nods. He settles his knees comfortably.

"Like we practiced," Jennifer prompts him.

You cup Chris's buttocks and squeeze again. Tight and muscular, a runner's butt. His balls are snugged tight in their sack, and the seam of his cock root runs back up to your target zone. You see Chris's butthole do a little wink when you spread his cheeks.

"Okay," he sighs. "It's really real."

"Yup," you say. "If that's what you want." You grab your cock and slide the tip up and down his crack. Your eyes flick toward Jennifer. Excitement shows in her face, and her nipples are swollen with arousal. You look back along Chris's body. "How could I let my best friend down?" Though your own excitement comes as much from Jennifer's promise to you.

"Let's do it," Chris says.

"Rocket ready," you say. "Say when."

"Ready," Chris says.

You arrange yourself on target, tip to Chris's tight butthole with its little wreath of golden hair, and push.

"Huh," you say. "Not getting anywhere." It's slippery and you feel Chris's knot moving under your cock tip, but nothing's happening. The first time you tried it with your old girlfriend, it was really slow. But that was her first time too. You stay in place patiently, not pushing any harder.

Jennifer bends down and whispers in Chris's ear. He breathes deeply, nods his head and grunts, pressing out at you. There's a little pop-pop! and Chris opens and takes you in.

"Wow," Chris says.

"Wow. Bro." you say.

"Yeah," Chris says.

"Tight," you say. You're in him, head-deep. You close your eyes and start a new count of your sexual experiences. "One," you whisper. Maybe that's as high as it'll ever go.

"Huh," Chris says. "You're big."

Jennifer holds Chris's head and kisses his cheek, murmurs in his ear, then turns his head to kiss his lips. Watching Jennifer loving up on Chris is a turn-on. You wonder if you should invite Chris when you collect on Jennifer's promise, or keep her all to yourself.

Jennifer whispers in Chris's ear again.

"Yeah," Chris replies. "Good. More lube maybe."

Jennifer sits up. She grins at you. "This is better than I imagined." She takes the bottle. "Let me get you really slippery." Jennifer's fingers dance up and down your shaft, slicking the lube in a thick coat, and finally tickling your balls.

"Whoa!" You twitch at the surprise tickle.

Jennifer laughs. "More, Chris?" she asks.

"Yeah. Okay, John?"

"Okay." You press forward again. The extra lube helps, and you feel his ring slide smoothly up your shaft. Chris groans, but presses back at you. Your balls bump against his cock root. Your shaft is balls-deep in your best friend's hot ass. "Wow. All the way."

"So beautiful," Jennifer says. She moves around and looks at you both from behind. "Wow," she breathes from behind you. "Your balls...both of you. John, feel how tight Chris is."

Jennifer guides your fingers down. Chris's balls ARE tight. Really tight.

You laugh. "Better get on his cock, then," you say.

"Just a sec," Jennifer says. She digs something out of her bag and gets behind you again. "God that's pretty. Balls over balls."

"Huh?" you say.

You hear a Click! and a little flash of light blinks from behind you.

"Hey!" you say.

"Don't worry, just a little close-up," Jennifer says.

Jennifer tucks her cameraphone back in her bag. You figure you'll have to deal with this later.

"You gonna join the party?" you ask Jennifer.

"Yes, sir!" she says with a big smile. "Chris baby, you ready for me?"

"Oh baby," Chris says. "Oh yeah, Jennifer."

"Let me get you real wet," she says. Another handful of lube goes up and down Chris's cock. "You're so hard."

Jennifer slides in under Chris face up, propping up her butt with a couple of pillows to put herself in line with Chris's cock. She pulls up her knees, spreading herself wide open. You feel Chris shifting under you, pulling you around by your cock, and then pressing his hips forward away from you.

"Ahhhhh!" Jennifer moans, followed by Chris's "Unnnnnh!" as they connect. Football player cock up sweet innocent cheerleader ass. It's nasty high school heaven. And Chris has a cock up his ass. Is that heaven or hell?

"Heaven," you mutter. Gotta do right by your best friend. And might as well earn your day with Jennifer.

You start thrusting slowly. Chris whimpers as he feels you move, but quickly starts moving with you.

"Ah, ah, ah, ah, ahh..." Chris sighs along with your thrusts. He moves along, thrusting into Jennifer, who looks up at both of you, wide-eyed.

Chris drops his head down and pauses, holding still against your thrusts for a moment, just feeling you move in him.

Jennifer catches your eye and silently mouths "Thank you!"

You nod and give her a crooked smile. Chris gets back in rhythm with you, and now you're all moving together.

"Mmmmh," you say. "Yeah." It's starting to feel really good. You like watching Jennifer, her cute angel face changing from expression to expression as you hold the rhythm, driving Chris's cock up her ass. Chris is breathing hard, panting out loud like he's struggling with a workout. You feel Chris's ass squeeze down on your shaft and his butt muscles tense and relax under your cupped hands.

Your cock swells inside Chris's ass. "Oh wow," you breathe. So soon, and you're already feeling close to coming.

"Oh John," Jennifer says, watching your face over Chris's shoulder. "You gonna come?"

You feel like you could. Pretty crazy, but hey, there you are. Or maybe if you hold off a little, maybe Chris will get off first. That would be wild. What would it feel like to be up a guy's ass while he was coming?

What do you do?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)