Be Nice and Warn Her

After she has been so nice to you, you cannot take the chance of knocking her up.

"I...I can't...I...switched your pills," you admit shamefully.

She pauses for a moment and then rolls her eyes.

"I know you did. It's okay. Just cum in me and we'll talk about it."

You nod happily and finally stop holding back. She squeezes her cunt tightly on your dick to push you over the edge.

"That's it! I'm cumming!"

"That's it! Give it all to me," Mariah exclaims.

A torrent of built-up juices shoot out of you and into the cheerleader's pussy. The extra stimulation in her pushes her over the edge as well.

"I'm cumming too! I'm cum-ming too!"

You both rub against each other in orgasmic bliss for a good minute or two. You both take your time recovering your energy.

"Do you..want to talk about it now," you ask curiously.

"Sure...No time like the pre-sent. So, why did you do it?"

"I don't...I'm not sure why. It was before...all this happened. I wanted to get back at you for what happened. I'm...not a good person."

"Relax," Mariah says calmly, "I'm not mad. It was no worse than anything Brad did to you."

"But I almost...I mean, I could of..."

"No, you couldn't of. I have been on the pill for a while. I recognized a placebo when I tasted it. That's why I just used my other bottle."

"Why did you tell me otherwise," you ask, "I don't understand."

"I knew that most of what I told you would somehow get to your parents and to mine. I had to cover my bases."

"So you forgive me?"

"If I didn't, would I still be sitting on your dick," she asks directly, "Really now."

"It's a relief to know that you are a better person than I thought. I think I could grow to love you."

"You didn't disappoint on your end either. Not just in the sex department either. I could...really grow to love you too."

"I've never been happier in my life," you express honestly.

"Let's fix that. You ready for another round? Because, honey, I want to top this moment for sure."