Are you kidding me? I'm not pulling out now!

( Authors note: This option starts a storyline in which Abby gets pregnant. If you're not into that pick the other option ;-) )

Your balls physically twitch as cum surges up your throbbing cock. You shoot five thick jets of cum, one after another into Abigail's fertile nineteen year old womb.

The two of you just lie there for a minute, panting and completely out of breath. You are still inside of her feeling every heartbeat all the way to the tip of your dick.

Finally she starts to really come to her senses and begins to push you off mumbling: "no, no no, no...please no".

You get off her, your cock slipping out. A small deluge of cum drips out of her violated throbbing cunt.

"Fuck fuck fuck! you came inside of me!", she exclaims, "I'm not on the pill you idiot, my parents wont let me!".

You realize you are relieved. For a moment you thought she hated what you two just did, after all it did kind of start out with you blackmailing her...

Using her index finger she's trying to scoop as much cum out of her drenched teenage pussy as she possibly can. You're not really sure what to say and you just hand her some tissues.

You realize that getting your nineteen year old babysitter pregnant would, although kinda hot, not be preferable and you ask her if she wants to use your shower, maybe she can get a bit more out that way. Abigail looks at you for a moment before hesitantly taking you up on your offer.

You put on your pants again and clean up around the couch. You realize that there are definitely some stains there that you'll need to get out before your wife gets back.

Abby gets out of the shower and after putting on her clothes she looks at you. Things are a little bit awkward.

"Look", you start, "I'll delete the video if you want..".

Abby smiles and looks thoughtful for a moment before answering: "nah you know what? as long as you don't show it to anyone I don't mind you having it".

She walks over to you pressing her tight frame with her big tits against yours and whispers: "we're good" before kissing you passionately.

You make out for a bit but you are both pretty beat up after everything that happened tonight and Abigail heads home.

As she heads out the door she looks back at you and winks.

"See you tomorrow mr. Doe" she says innocently.