Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Unity Unity

Who do you pick?

"Cookie & Cream"

Something that stuck out to you were two identical pictures placed side by side. The picture was of two young catboys embracing each other. Their tongue were in the middle of a heated wrestling match, and they kept their lips apart to ensure the camera caught the lines of spit that connected the two intertwined muscles. Unlike most of the nekos on the wall, these two were staring into each other's eyes, not the camera.

One of the nekos was a lanky black man, probably around 20. He had pointy black cat ears poking out through a mop of hair, that were covered with white splotches. The same white on black splotch design was present on this catboy's tail.

The other neko was more "filled in" with better muscle definition than his lover, but he was the shorter of the two and he looked to be the younger one as well. He had pale white skin, and a pair of white fluffy ears poking through his dirty blonde hair. Mirroring the black catboy, this one's ears and tail had black splotches on them.

Below the two identical pictures were two different collars. One black and one white, with little brass tags dangling from metal loops, which read "Cookie" and "Cream" respectively. It was impossible for you to tell who was who, but you grabbed both collars anyways and prayed the catboys would introduce themselves.

You brought the collars up to Beans, who traded you in return for your coffee. A tiny paper cup filled with dark brown liquid.

"Cookie and Cream. Those are actually our two most popular extra shots. I'll go get them sir, you find a place to sit." When Beans turns around you finally notice that he isn't wearing pants. His lower half was conveniently hidden behind the counter this whole time, and only now do you notice his plump ass jiggling as he walks away.

As Beans heads into the backroom, that hot ass unfortunately following him, you turn around and examine the available seating options.

A reclining chair might be uncomfortable for three people to sit in, of course cats are known to be flexible and, for lack of a better word, compressable. The loveseat is more spacious, as is the three piece leather couch. Or you could ask about the private rooms in the back.

Where do you sit?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)